User Panel
Posted: 4/30/2015 3:43:52 PM EDT
If you are rushing to the hospital to save a loved one, and are detained by police for speeding and that detainment risks the life of your loved one, are you justified in fleeing? In similar stories below, one man was shot by police and another died. One cop asked for written proof of the wife's breast cancer while he detained them for a speeding ticket as the wife suffered severe chest pains from blood clots in her lungs. Another man died on the side of the road from an asthma attack because the cop wouldn't let them drive to the hospital (they were 3 miles from hospital). If you try to flee like the Marine below, you risk the cop jumping in front of your car to stop you, and then doing a mag dump on you claiming you used your car as a weapon. It seems there is no winning in a case like this.
Camp Lejeune Marine Shot by Police While Rushing Wife to Hospital. http://woundedtimes.blogspot.com/2014/11/camp-lejeune-marine-shot-by-police.html Man Dies During Traffic Stop From Asthma Attack as Cop Refuses to Let them Drive to Hospital http://thefreethoughtproject.com/man-dies-traffic-stop-asthma-attack-cop-refuses-drive-hospital/ Man said he was trying to take his wife, Roxanna, who has stage 4 breast cancer, to the hospital because she was having severe chest pains. Detained for 15 minutes by cop for speeding http://www.wsbtv.com/news/news/local/man-stopped-police-while-rushing-wife-hospital/nFJjn/ Man Rushing to Wife In Labor Says Cop Pulled Gun on Him During Traffic Stop http://abcnews.go.com/US/dad-police-officer-pulled-gun-traffic-stop/story?id=27647407 Pregnant Woman in Labor Forced to Ground Held at Gunpoint By Cops for Speeding to Hospital http://thefreethoughtproject.com/police-set-tire-spikes-stop-woman-labor-speeding-hold-gunpoint/ Man charged with 7 felonies for rushing his wife to hospital, who just had a stroke, http://newsroom.blogs.cnn.com/2010/06/22/cop-arrest-man-man-was-rushing-wife-to-er/ |
|
You can always call 911 on the way if a cop is behind you. I'm not stopping if it's that life threatening.
|
|
Justified or not - yer gonna end up with a pile of fellows on you when you reach your destination...
|
|
Quoted: You can always call 911 on the way if a cop is behind you. I'm not stopping if it's that life threatening. View Quote This, or just let him follow you to the hospital. I'd be more than willing to get arrested and go in front of a judge and explain that one, if it meant saving a loved one's life. Speed |
|
Quoted:
This, or just let him follow you to the hospital. I'd be more than willing to get arrested and go in front of a judge and explain that one, if it meant saving a loved one's life. Speed View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
You can always call 911 on the way if a cop is behind you. I'm not stopping if it's that life threatening. This, or just let him follow you to the hospital. I'd be more than willing to get arrested and go in front of a judge and explain that one, if it meant saving a loved one's life. Speed Remember that video of the guy dying of a heart attack, getting to the hospital, only to have the LEO hold him at gun point and beating his wife. Neither the husband or wife respected his authority. |
|
In before the "you stop when and where I tell you to stop" gestapo
|
|
Quoted: Remember that video of the guy dying of a heart attack, getting to the hospital, only to have the LEO hold him at gun point and beating his wife. Neither the husband or wife respected his authority. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: You can always call 911 on the way if a cop is behind you. I'm not stopping if it's that life threatening. This, or just let him follow you to the hospital. I'd be more than willing to get arrested and go in front of a judge and explain that one, if it meant saving a loved one's life. Speed Remember that video of the guy dying of a heart attack, getting to the hospital, only to have the LEO hold him at gun point and beating his wife. Neither the husband or wife respected his authority. I've had run ins with insane cops (like, actual mental health disorders), but...I thinks that's more of the exception and not the norm I'd have to take the chance if it was a life or death situation. Besides, if I made it to the ER and the cop beat the fuck out of me...I'd already be at the hospital! Speed |
|
Do you even read the articles you posted?
First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. |
|
It seems like a pretty unusual situation where blasting your way through police roadblocks is faster than calling 911 and letting the firemen spin their lights and rush to the hospital.
I suppose if my wife was squirting blood from an artery that I was trying to hold close as I rushed to the hospital five blocks away I'd just keep going and let them arrest me at the ER. |
|
Yes, but we've been trained to believe that we deserve jail or death if we do.
|
|
Look, the only reason I stop now is because I'm a good person. In reality there is fuck all that they can do if a loved one is dying on me. Cause I aint stopping and they can meet me at the hospital.
My slowest vehicle is still faster than their quickest one The fact that I will have East Bound and Down blaring is completely inconsequential |
|
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. View Quote That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. |
|
Quoted:
That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. Uhh it's in the articles. |
|
Quoted: It seems like a pretty unusual situation where blasting your way through police roadblocks is faster than calling 911 and letting the firemen spin their lights and rush to the hospital. View Quote Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. |
|
If it's 1950 in Mississippi and you're black, then yes, you are justified in running like hell.
|
|
lulz |
|
I'm armed and law-abiding, therefore, I really have no use for cops. If I need one, I'll call one.
|
|
I can't think of any time its ok to run from the cops. I'm a bit fuzzier on just not stopping till you get to your destination.
The one time I had to get someone to the hospital quickly, I didn't get stopped and the cop who did show up ran interference for me at intersections. I was on the phone with 911 at the time. I think the vast majority of cops would have done the same. |
|
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. View Quote Sorry, but reading the facts and making an informed decision based on those facts is not how's it's done in GD. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. Uhh it's in the articles. Please stop interfering with his agenda. |
|
Quoted:
If you are rushing to the hospital to save a loved one, and are detained by police for speeding and that detainment risks the life of your loved one, are you justified in fleeing? In similar stories below, one man was shot by police and another died. One cop asked for written proof of the wife's breast cancer while he detained them for a speeding ticket while the wife suffered chest pains from blood clots in her lungs. Another man died on the side of the road from an asthma attack because the cop wouldn't let them drive to the hospital (they were 3 miles from hospital). If you try to flee like the Marine below, you risk the cop jumping in front of your car to stop you, and then doing a mag dump on you claiming you used your car as a weapon. It seems there is no winning in a case like this. Camp Lejeune Marine Shot by Police While Rushing Wife to Hospital. http://woundedtimes.blogspot.com/2014/11/camp-lejeune-marine-shot-by-police.html Man Dies During Traffic Stop From Asthma Attack as Cop Refuses to Let them Drive to Hospital http://thefreethoughtproject.com/man-dies-traffic-stop-asthma-attack-cop-refuses-drive-hospital/ Man said he was trying to take his wife, Roxanna, who has stage 4 breast cancer, to the hospital because she was having severe chest pains. Detained for 15 minutes by cop for speeding http://www.wsbtv.com/news/news/local/man-stopped-police-while-rushing-wife-hospital/nFJjn/ Man Rushing to Wife In Labor Says Cop Pulled Gun on Him During Traffic Stop http://abcnews.go.com/US/dad-police-officer-pulled-gun-traffic-stop/story?id=27647407 View Quote 3 of your 4 are tough shit situations. The guy who was having an asthma attack - I hope that cop finds karma unkind. |
|
Quoted:
Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
It seems like a pretty unusual situation where blasting your way through police roadblocks is faster than calling 911 and letting the firemen spin their lights and rush to the hospital. Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. Except you will receive emergency care when they arrive and during transit. Plus you hardly ever get shot by cops while riding in the back of an ambulance. |
|
|
If I was rushing someone to the hospital, Id be calling 911 ahead of time, give warning to the ER and the LEO in the area, so maybe they could help and they would know its not someone that just committed a crime, etc.
|
|
If I had a loved one in a life or death situation I wouldn't stop for them.
What happens after happens |
|
Quoted:
. Plus you hardly ever get shot by cops while riding in the back of an ambulance. View Quote https://www.google.com/?gws_rd=ssl#q=cop+pulls+over+ambulance You may not get shot but the driver might get choked. |
|
Quoted: Except you will receive emergency care when they arrive and during transit. Plus you hardly ever get shot by cops while riding in the back of an ambulance. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: It seems like a pretty unusual situation where blasting your way through police roadblocks is faster than calling 911 and letting the firemen spin their lights and rush to the hospital. Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. Except you will receive emergency care when they arrive and during transit. Plus you hardly ever get shot by cops while riding in the back of an ambulance. Emergency Health service response REALLY depends on the locality... The responders in my parent's county are 100% volunteer, keep the response vehicles at there house (no station), and the average response time is 30 minutes. Compare that with the fact my parents live 20 minutes from the nearest hospital... |
|
Run from The Police? Absolutely! Especially when they start that screeching "Roxanne" crap! Somebody should have ripped out his throat back in the '80's.
Of course if I must disobey a cop's light and direction to pull over, it's because the situation demanded it (life threatening if I did not take the action). Flashers on, sane speed, and on the phone to 911. BTW, I live within 2 miles of the hospital, but the ambulance service is based out of the north side of town - 6 miles through city traffic. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. Uhh it's in the articles. You are not fooling anyone. You are the one that needs to read the articles. You should take some reading comprehension classes too. 1. "Henry says her husband was only trying to go around the policeman when the officer opened fire." 2. "However, she was only hysterical because her boyfriend was dying and being kept from life saving treatment that could have saved his life." [turns out she was right, because he died] 3. "He said the officer took about 15 minutes and gave him a citation." "I said 'Sir, I don't want to sign it. I just want to leave and go to the hospital.' He said, 'If you don't sign it I'm going to take you to jail,’” said White. 4. So what??? The guy was 7/10th of a mile from his house and he was rushing there because his wife was in labor and needed to get to the hospital. |
|
I have been told by local cops that if I am rushing someone to the ER they wouldn't care. That being said, the nearest fire station is 10 min away with a 15-20 min response time. The nearest Hospital is 30 min away, and when my mother had an extremely severe allergic reaction to fish I was able to get her there in under 10 min. The docs said another 5-10 min she would have been worm food.
That being said I am a rather proficient driver, and have a car made to go fast. had it been less serious I would have just called 911. ETA: I would also get a cop dog pile and ensure my loved ones are safe, than risk their lives to mind a cops EGO. Fortunately the cops here are generally cool about things, and cant keep up with me |
|
Quoted: 3 of your 4 are tough shit situations. The guy who was having an asthma attack - I hope that cop finds karma unkind. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: If you are rushing to the hospital to save a loved one, and are detained by police for speeding and that detainment risks the life of your loved one, are you justified in fleeing? In similar stories below, one man was shot by police and another died. One cop asked for written proof of the wife's breast cancer while he detained them for a speeding ticket while the wife suffered chest pains from blood clots in her lungs. Another man died on the side of the road from an asthma attack because the cop wouldn't let them drive to the hospital (they were 3 miles from hospital). If you try to flee like the Marine below, you risk the cop jumping in front of your car to stop you, and then doing a mag dump on you claiming you used your car as a weapon. It seems there is no winning in a case like this. Camp Lejeune Marine Shot by Police While Rushing Wife to Hospital. http://woundedtimes.blogspot.com/2014/11/camp-lejeune-marine-shot-by-police.html Man Dies During Traffic Stop From Asthma Attack as Cop Refuses to Let them Drive to Hospital http://thefreethoughtproject.com/man-dies-traffic-stop-asthma-attack-cop-refuses-drive-hospital/ Man said he was trying to take his wife, Roxanna, who has stage 4 breast cancer, to the hospital because she was having severe chest pains. Detained for 15 minutes by cop for speeding http://www.wsbtv.com/news/news/local/man-stopped-police-while-rushing-wife-hospital/nFJjn/ Man Rushing to Wife In Labor Says Cop Pulled Gun on Him During Traffic Stop http://abcnews.go.com/US/dad-police-officer-pulled-gun-traffic-stop/story?id=27647407 3 of your 4 are tough shit situations. The guy who was having an asthma attack - I hope that cop finds karma unkind. I agree. Fuck that guy! |
|
I'm pretty sure 1st step in the process is call 911.
Then you need to make the call on whether you can get to the hospital quicker then the ambulance/EMT's can get to you. I had a coworker start showing signs of a heart attack at work 30 miles from the nearest hospital. One of the other guys loaded him in his truck and started towards the hospital while on the phone with 911. They sent an ambulance and met him halfway, no cops were ever involved, and the guy lived after heart surgery. |
|
I could actually hear it. Alllahhh ackbbarrrrrr |
|
|
As a kid we ran from the cops all the time. TP a house run! Throw eggs at cars run! Nowadays seems like you get your ass shot for doing stupid shit that kids do.
|
|
Quoted: I'm pretty sure 1st step in the process is call 911. Then you need to make the call on whether you can get to the hospital quicker then the ambulance/EMT's can get to you. I had a coworker start showing signs of a heart attack at work 30 miles from the nearest hospital. One of the other guys loaded him in his truck and started towards the hospital while on the phone with 911. They sent an ambulance and met him halfway, no cops were ever involved, and the guy lived after heart surgery. View Quote Sometimes I think people lose their fucking decision making ability in proximity to LE. |
|
I can point to nine people that have died rushing someone to the hospital. One case was a triple fatality. (one-ton Chevy Vs Toyota Corolla. )
You are not the hot-shit rally driver you think you are. Go right ahead and try it, It's just more OT for whoever is doing the crash investigation. |
|
LOL Man you always bring the best IN memes |
|
Quoted: Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: It seems like a pretty unusual situation where blasting your way through police roadblocks is faster than calling 911 and letting the firemen spin their lights and rush to the hospital. Who said anything about police roadblocks? Depending on the situation, the person might get treatment faster by getting in the car and head down to the hospital vs waiting on them to come to you and then head back. I'd say this is especially the case in rural areas. |
|
|
what the fuck lol |
|
Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. Uhh it's in the articles. ibtss |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Do you even read the articles you posted? First one admitted they intentionally ran from the cops and tried to run an officer down. Second one the GF could not safely operate the vehicle she was freaking out so bad. The third one the driver refused to sign the speeding ticket citation that is why the stop lasted so long. The fourth one he refused to stop for the cops driving to his house not to the hospital. That's your version of events, which we know is nearly always distorted to favor your agenda. Uhh it's in the articles. No you have an agenda, OK? |
|
I've been stopped many times enroute to the hospital
I always stop. Sometimes I'm polite, sometimes I'm manipulative-depends on why I'm in such a hurry For instance, once I was enroute to deliver a baby. Pulled over by a noobie, fresh out of academy flatfoot. He wished to demonstrate his authority by not immediately letting me be on my way. UNTIL I asked him his name. His response, "Why, are you going to file a complaint against me?" I told him no, that I merely wanted to have a name to communicate to the expectant mom and dad, so they would know who to complain about because I missed being at the hospital to deliver the baby. Another time, I was enroute to see a patient who was seizing uncontrollably. I saw the cop way down the road, so I stepped up my speed "a little". I thought he going to crash trying to get turned around to stop me. I pulled over. He came waddling up, (literally), and was PISSED. He asked if I knew how fast I was going. I said I had a general idea. (About 82, in a 35, for those interested. In a Porsche 968. Cabriolet). I guess the dispatcher told him who I was because he was in turbo-waddle when he returned to my car. He screamed, "are you the doctor?". I said yes. He threw my DL and CHL in the car and yelled, "Go, go, get out of here!" I vapor locked and had trouble seeing to get to the hospital because I was laughing so hard. BUT, I ALWAYS STOP |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.