So then, why hasn't the president issued a call for volunteers? Something
more than money is at stake, I think. The premise of a call for volunteers
is that, if the summons doesn't work, we resort to a draft. But that puts us
right back in the political soup. And that is why neither the Joint Chiefs
nor the administration are being frank with the American people about our
readiness problems. A call for volunteers would be an admission that we do
not have enough troops. That admission, all by itself, would be sufficient
to raise the specter of a draft, and that would send the president's
approval ratings plummeting.
There's just one tiny little problem. Politics or no, we are not prepared
for this war. The attack on Iraq could set off any number of unexpected
military problems that would tax our already overstretched forces beyond
their limits. Last week, I mentioned a few. Last month, on NRO, Adam
Mersereau laid out several more. So either we go into Iraq on a bet that
there will be no serious complications, or we fail to invade Iraq for want
of military readiness, without even acknowledging to ourselves that this is
the reason. And if we do go in and suffer an emergency in which only a draft
can provide us with combat replacements, will there really be time to pass
the legislation, resolve the tough questions about deferment and women,
train the troops, and get them to the field in time?
Let me offer a suggestion, one that came from a reader who sang the praises
of the Junior ROTC. The JROTC appears to be a tremendously positive program
for building character, citizenship — and military readiness — among
America's youth. And of course, there's the college ROTC itself. What if the
president were to call for institution of JROTC programs in every American
public high school? Above all, what if the president were to insist that any
college or university that takes even a penny of federal money must make a
place for the ROTC?
This move would neither entirely solve the military's problem, nor
necessarily forestall a politically explosive discussion of military
readiness. But it is a reasonable stab at a halfway house. If not in the
short term, then at least in the medium and long term, growth in JROTC and
ROTC might solve much of our manpower needs, and do it with volunteers. And
presidential interest in these programs would be a clear, but also a
somewhat safe and oblique way to publicly raise the issue of our manpower
needs.