Quoted:
Yup, but you can turn around and sell those already paid for Galils on the open market for hard cash and arm your troops with free rifles from the US.
View Quote
Yes, but they could also turn around and sell the M4/M16 rifles as well. They could probably get more money for the M4/M16 rifles.
Quoted:
[edited for length -James]
IMI Galil 5.56mm AR
Barrel length 16.1 in
Overall length Stock extended: 36.5 in
Weight unloaded 8.6 lb
[M16A2]
39.25" OVERALL LENGTH
20" BARREL LENGTH
WEIGHT W/O MAG. - 7.5 LBS (3.4 KG)
WEIGHT W/LOADED MAG. - 8.75 LBS (4 KG)
It seems like the Galil is actually a little LIGHTER than the M16A2.
View Quote
From your data, it would seem that the M16A2 is actually lighter than the Galil when comparing unloaded weight to unloaded weight. In fact, your data above suggests that the M16A2 is only 4 ounces heavier *fully loaded* than an unloaded Galil. In addition, you get a 4 inch longer barrel with only a 2.75 inch longer overall length.
We should take Mr. Cohen at his word, that the M4/M16 platform is preferred over the AK/Galil platform regardless of "backroom deals" claimed here. (Full Disclosure: I copied and pasted his response on tacticalforums.com.)
In fact, all of the online media I have read indicates that the U.S. gives Israel cash at the beginning of the year. I have read no evidence that "buy American" is ever stipulated. Someone please post a link substantiating this.
I do not know why people are so surprised that the M4/M16 is preferred over AK/Galil variants. The M16 is a more recent design using more sophisticated manufacturing technology than the stamped AK design. The M16 package is more efficient in terms of OAL than the Galil. A longer barrel improves the terminal ballistics of the 5.56x45mm.
Now before someone chimes in with M16/AK caliber argument, I will. Bullets incapacitate by...
1) Destroying the central nervous system [CNS](brain or spinal cord shot)
2) Destroying tissue and causing bleeding
3) Destroying function (i.e., destroying the function of the shooting hand, arm, etc.)
4) Psychologically incapacitating them (the get shot and don't want to fight no more)
A CNS shot (#1) is difficult and only luck will ensure a destroying shot (#3). No one would want to depend on a psychological stop (#4) so we are left with destroying tissue and causing bleeding (#2).
Note that the blood does not need to leave the body to "bleed" ...just leave the control of the circulatory system. Flesh cut/destroyed internally is "bleeding." The brain senses loss of circulatory "pressure" and shuts down the body to preserve circulatory pressure to the brain. The 5.56x45 rounds destroy more tissue at close range than 7.62x39 rounds so long as the barrel length allows the 5.56 to accelerate past the 2500-2700fps that ensures reliable fragmentation.
[continued...]