PCGOD,
if that were a compromise, maybe some Anti's would go for it, thinking that registration would DO something. (it really won't... if we recall New Zealand threw out their registration because it was useless)
Most of us would hate to be registered, but if it worked out like you proposed, like a national CCW, I'd ONLY go for it if it included provisions PERMANENTLY RESTRICTING any sort of registration of my arms, and PERMANENTLY restricted any retention of my name/address in any lists.
The government should only maintain lists of CRIMINALS. I have no problem providing positive ID, and having to go through a background check at the point of sale, as long as it's INSTANT.
I really don't think many other gunnies would go for what you propose, but it's good idea to debate with some anti's... see how they react to a proposed 'compromise'
M@