What I like about them is that I don't have to use them.
I put them on my dogs, they behave, I never have to correct. I could tie a sewing thread to that collar and they would still heal.
My wife and I were 100% against those evil torture devices. We tried a ton of different collars (buckle, choke, martingale, gentle leader, etc).
We then went to a trainer that showed us how they work and how to use them.
My pitt mix pulled on a collar so hard, you could tie her to your car and she would tow it down the road. She hit the prongs once and got it. Now, she doesn't choke herself when she walks. I'm happy, she's happy and the collar just sits around her neck ready to be used if it's needed.
I now have them for all my dogs.
The one thing I have learned, however, is that I use a cheap carabiner to hook the prong collar to the normal buckle collar on the dog. I have had the prongs pop loose before (my current model has a punch clip, which works great, but can still release if caught on something). So, if the collar releases, the carabiner still holds onto the regular collar.