Quoted:
Looks like I might be taking a different direction away from the Cayenne and the Range Rover towards the FX37. I like the infiniti and am familiar with the line already. The 1st gens fall into my price range. I am looking from you guys in the know about Nissan's VQ35 engine and their reliability or other issues that I might have with this SUV.
I had a 2005 FX35 AWD for less than a year that I had bought used. It was a love/hate relationship. I really liked the styling of it and for a crossover it drove very nicely. Decent power too. While getting in & out of the back seats was a little awkward, there was plenty of backseat room for adults. My kids were very comfortable back there. The cargo room in the hatch area was a little limited but not horrible. It felt very solid.
I ended up getting rid of it because it turned out to be somewhat of a lemon. I've had other Nissan products before that weren't nearly as problematic so I am inclined to think mine was more of a fluke. However, there were enough problems for me to get rid of it. When I bought it, it had 62k miles and had 78k miles on it when I traded it in.
- I had the dash bubbling problem that luckily was covered under the extended warranty that Infiniti created for that problem.
- Both power mirror motors crapped out. Luckily replacing them was easy enough to do myself.
- Ignition coils started going bad which in turn killed the catalytic converters. The dealer got the converters covered under the longer emissions warranty (good thing as they were $1000 each) but I had to pay for multiple new coils then eventually a whole new set when the underlying problem was found. Turns out there was a TSB for the issue. Bad grounds were the problem and required new grounding cables.
- Transmission failed. It started hesitating going into reverse until eventually it just wouldn't go into reverse at all. I don't remember what the entire bill was but it was at least $5k.
The transmission was the final straw as I did not want to keep it anymore without a warranty. It's too bad because otherwise I really liked it. I would not be against getting another one but I would not get one without an extended warranty. My brother had an Infiniti G37S around the same time that was mostly problem free so like I said mine was probably just a fluke.