The wife and I want to get ourselves in better shape, and lose some weight. Unfortunately, with my busted leg, there isn't a great deal that I can do at the moment. I'm 40, she's 45. Both programs look pretty good. We do like the less time during workout of Insanity, and the fact that we don't need to buy the pull-up bar (not a deal breaker). We do already have barbells, so that's not to worry.

My Uncle, Brother, friends and myself have all done both. Insanity hurt all of our backs. But P90X is really great, dont skimp on the yoga or stretching. You WILL see great results.

Insanity tore my lower legs up, all that jumping around takes a toll on your body.If those are the choices P90x all the way.