User Panel
Posted: 8/20/2017 7:42:56 PM EDT
Hello everyone. I currently live in Illinois. My family and I are moving and Minnesota is one of the states we are looking at. We have narrowed it down to Montana, Minnesota, or Wisconsin. Illinois gun laws suck but aren't horrible. We can own ARs and other semiauto sporting rifles, we can possess standard capacity magazines and higher, we have carry now and even can have sbrs. We don't have registration or any bullshit. The only thing we have is the FOID card. Basically you fill out a form similar to the 4473 and are issued a card that is good for ten years. This card allows you to buy firearms and ammo (still need to fill out 4473 every time). That is really the only shitty thing. We also can't have suppressor which sucks. I'm not looking to move to another state that is more restrictive than my current state.
In MN, do you need any kind of permit for rifles, handguns, "assault rifles" ( better known as semi auto sporting rifles)? Any registration or stupid hoops to jump through to get a carry license? I've done a bit of looking around and it doesn't seem like there is any issues but I wanted to ask you all so I don't miss anything. We are a very active family. We love being outdoors hiking, fishing, shooting , kayaking etc. We want to move somewhere that better resembles our life style. Any insight you can give me is much appreciated. Thanks. ETA: how are the politics in your state? Are dems likely to overtake your state in the near future? Here in Illinois the dems pretty much have everything on lock down. Our gun rights are safe for the time being because of the southern democrats. They generally vote against that nonsense. |
|
Mn is pretty good on gun laws and getting better with the help of a very active gun rights lobby group
SBRs are good to go, as are supressors. No SBS or non C&R machine guns To buy ammo, just walk in and buy it, you might get carded for age verification To buy handguns or "assault rifles" you need to either have a valid Carry Permit or a Permit to Purchase. The permit to purchase is a bit of a left over from before the NICS system IIRC, and is free to obtain. Just head to your local police dept and fill out the form. There has been talk about getting rid of this as it is pretty pointless. Politics are...ok here, our current governor is a POS but he is not running for re-election and there has been a definite move to conservatism outside of the MLPS/ST.Paul metro area. Hope you choose MN, we need more gun nuts up here. Oh, and the one HTF mod is a real tool. I saw that |
|
Minnesota does require a permit to purchase handguns and "assault weapons," which is free and good for year, and requires just a trip to your local PD to fill out a background check form. There is no registration requirement, and private purchase doesn't require a permit (though many private sellers require one). Our permit to carry also covers the permit to purchase, so if you get your PTC, you don't need the purchase permit. PTC is good for five years and does require a class, but most classes are a single day and seem to run $80-100. Permit fees vary, but they're capped at (I believe) $100 or $125. Most of the rural counties are quite a bit cheaper than that. Also, a new PTC would be good in lieu of the 4473, assuming your FFL is good with doing so.
Most NFA stuff is good to go, though we still can't have non-C&R full auto or SBS. I think all three of your options would be excellent for outdoors-minded people. Minnesota is very heavily invested in its public land system -- to the point where I think there would be pretty minimal impact in this state even if there were complete federal land divestiture. Our DNR isn't perfect, but the options in this state for public land access are pretty incredible throughout the state. Northern Minnesota offers ridiculous hiking and canoeing/kayaking opportunities, between the Superior National Forest and Boundary Waters, and there are many places for those activities in the rest of the state as well. Due to the way our population is distributed and the politics of Northeastern Minnesota, the Democrats have a strong hold on the state. I don't know how it would compare to Illinois, but taxes can get pretty high in the urban/suburban areas. We have a statewide sales tax (groceries and clothes exempt), income tax, property tax, etc. -- you won't be getting any major tax benefit here in the way you would in South Dakota, Wyoming, and the like. Gun laws have been generally liberalizing over the last few years, though there is almost always at least a token gun control law pushed by the Dems. Thus far, we've stopped them cold, and most of the non-Metro Democrats in the state are pretty lukewarm on gun control. Between the politics of the Iron Range, the politics of most of the Metro area, and our large and growing immigrant population, I don't see the Republicans making huge inroads in state politics any time soon. I live right in the middle of St. Paul; as soon as we've got a little more money socked away, the wife and I are moving out of the Metro area. If my only choices were to live in the Metro or move out of state, I'd be gone in a heartbeat. The Cities are SOLID blue and only moving further in that direction (Minneapolis passed a $15 minimum wage plan recently). A lot of the rural areas and smaller towns and cities are much more conservative minded and do their best to ignore the liberal parts of the state. I guess the TL;DR version would be you probably wouldn't regret moving here, as long as you don't live right in MSP or any of the first/second-ring suburbs |
|
|
Quoted:
And the number of places who actually card are pretty few and far between -- most of them (at least that I've ever been to) just ask for your DOB. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes |
|
Quoted:
Minnesota does require a permit to purchase handguns and "assault weapons," which is free and good for year, and requires just a trip to your local PD to fill out a background check form. There is no registration requirement, and private purchase doesn't require a permit (though many private sellers require one). Our permit to carry also covers the permit to purchase, so if you get your PTC, you don't need the purchase permit. PTC is good for five years and does require a class, but most classes are a single day and seem to run $80-100. Permit fees vary, but they're capped at (I believe) $100 or $125. Most of the rural counties are quite a bit cheaper than that. Also, a new PTC would be good in lieu of the 4473, assuming your FFL is good with doing so. Most NFA stuff is good to go, though we still can't have non-C&R full auto or SBS. I think all three of your options would be excellent for outdoors-minded people. Minnesota is very heavily invested in its public land system -- to the point where I think there would be pretty minimal impact in this state even if there were complete federal land divestiture. Our DNR isn't perfect, but the options in this state for public land access are pretty incredible throughout the state. Northern Minnesota offers ridiculous hiking and canoeing/kayaking opportunities, between the Superior National Forest and Boundary Waters, and there are many places for those activities in the rest of the state as well. Due to the way our population is distributed and the politics of Northeastern Minnesota, the Democrats have a strong hold on the state. I don't know how it would compare to Illinois, but taxes can get pretty high in the urban/suburban areas. We have a statewide sales tax (groceries and clothes exempt), income tax, property tax, etc. -- you won't be getting any major tax benefit here in the way you would in South Dakota, Wyoming, and the like. Gun laws have been generally liberalizing over the last few years, though there is almost always at least a token gun control law pushed by the Dems. Thus far, we've stopped them cold, and most of the non-Metro Democrats in the state are pretty lukewarm on gun control. Between the politics of the Iron Range, the politics of most of the Metro area, and our large and growing immigrant population, I don't see the Republicans making huge inroads in state politics any time soon. I live right in the middle of St. Paul; as soon as we've got a little more money socked away, the wife and I are moving out of the Metro area. If my only choices were to live in the Metro or move out of state, I'd be gone in a heartbeat. The Cities are SOLID blue and only moving further in that direction (Minneapolis passed a $15 minimum wage plan recently). A lot of the rural areas and smaller towns and cities are much more conservative minded and do their best to ignore the liberal parts of the state. I guess the TL;DR version would be you probably wouldn't regret moving here, as long as you don't live right in MSP or any of the first/second-ring suburbs View Quote I know it aint much, but it makes me think that the iron rangers and farmers are starting to realize that the DFL is not the the "Farm and Labor" party that their granddaddys voted for. |
|
|
Thanks for the info so far. We are not city people. We are not complete rural people either. We like moderate size towns within decent travel times to bigger areas. We don't go to chicago at all so I don't foresee going to the twin cities. The only time I have been there was for hospital stuff and I couldn't wait to get out. Nothing against the city. I just don't like being in them.
When you say you need a permit to purchase if you don't get a pro, what about ownership in general. I'd be. Moving with quite a few toys and probably wouldn't be buying anything for a while. Do I need any kind of permit to just own what I have currently? I'll eventually get my ptc but can't really say for sure when. I am very active in our gun rights groups here so if I move there it would be the same. Thanks again ETA: the part I hate most around here is you have to have your foid card on you at all times when handling or having any ammo or gun in your possession. |
|
MN doesn't have anything like the IL FOID. You can own whatever you like. See above for the exceptions to that. The permitting requirements are for purchasing not ownership.
The Democrat Party OWNS Minnesota & will for a long time to come. The presidential vote was a fluke & a pleasant surprise. The current Democrat governor is quitting after his current term & it's extremely unlikely that there will be a Republican replacement. The only politicians with any name recognition are the Democrats. Most people couldn't name a prominent Republican when the legislature isn't in session simply because the media only seems to bash them when they're in session or have an election coming up. Otherwise they mostly concentrate on Trump bashing. When we had a Republican governor a few years ago, Tim Pawlenty, most of the MNHTF member bashed him as a RINO which he most certainly wasn't. For a MN Republican he was quite conservative. He got us CCW. His only real fault was giving a billion of our dollars to the Vikings after opposing the new stadium as a legislator. It was a not-on-my-watch move on Pawlenty's part. The main difference between IL Democrats & MN Democrats is that IL Dems are overtly corrupt, or at least much moreso than the MN Dems. The MN Dems are passive aggressive & buy votes based on emotions & bullshit. Here's an example of Democrat perfidy: Minnesota has a Democrat led commission or board to govern every aspect of our lives, like the Minnesota Metropolitan Mosquito Control District & the Minnesota Sports Facilities Commission (MSFC). Anyway, the MSFC had to have two chair people for some reason. One was Ted Mondale, the son of the former MN senator, so it was quite obvious right there that the fix was in. The other was Michelle Kelm-Helgen who was the governor's former secretary. They each got paid $160,000 a year for essentially doing nothing, going to a few meetings every year. There was a big scandal, by MN standards at least, when it came out that Kelm-Helgen was found to have given free seats in the new Viking stadium suite to a bunch of her friends. Few records were kept so when it came to light some of those people paid a few bucks back for their seats, something like $160 each when they were valued at $1200(?) each. Anyway, Kelm-Helgen finally resigned a s a result of that scandal but not until she got her & some of her friends season tickets to every Vikings game on the 50 yard line. She made a point of saying she was sorry but apparently she wasn't sorry enough to give them back. Now she's faded into obscurity but her season tickets are still being used by her & her friends & family, actually for the first full season this year. BTW, there is now one chairwoman for the MSFC & she's part time & she gets maybe $60,000 a year. I guess you could check all the figures out to be sure that they're 100% correct but they're pretty close. Minneapolis & St. Paul seem to be on a kick of "I'm more Communist that you are. No, I'm more Communist that you are." They keep running goofy politicians who are in a contest to see how much of our money they can give away. As far a mid-sized cities, they are following as fast as they can. Rochester & St. Cloud used to be real nice cities but now they have all the crime that the Cities do. Duluth is probably leading the bunch toward full blown Communism, probably the result of the extreme Iron Range politics. The geography of MN is very nice & you have quite a range of things to choose from. There are the hills of SE MN, the great north woods, Lake Superior, 10,000 lakes, (actually there are more than 15,000), & probably the least appreciated part of the state, the prairies. Also, there are a lot of things to see & do in The Cities of course. There are a lot of good gun shows in the metro area. Look at the MWCA.org website. BTW, the in crowd uses the term "The Cities" not the Twin Cities. Good Luck OP. |
|
Quoted:
Thanks for the info so far. We are not city people. We are not complete rural people either. We like moderate size towns within decent travel times to bigger areas. We don't go to chicago at all so I don't foresee going to the twin cities. The only time I have been there was for hospital stuff and I couldn't wait to get out. Nothing against the city. I just don't like being in them. When you say you need a permit to purchase if you don't get a pro, what about ownership in general. I'd be. Moving with quite a few toys and probably wouldn't be buying anything for a while. Do I need any kind of permit to just own what I have currently? I'll eventually get my ptc but can't really say for sure when. I am very active in our gun rights groups here so if I move there it would be the same. Thanks again ETA: the part I hate most around here is you have to have your foid card on you at all times when handling or having any ammo or gun in your possession. View Quote Nothing needed to own or handle guns or to go shooting. GOCRA is the big 2a group here. They were responsible for stopping all the post sandy hook laws dead in their tracks. Great group. |
|
Quoted:
MN doesn't have anything like the IL FOID. You can own whatever you like. See above for the exceptions to that. The permitting requirements are for purchasing not ownership. The Democrat Party OWNS Minnesota & will for a long time to come. The presidential vote was a fluke & a pleasant surprise. The current Democrat governor is quitting after his current term & it's extremely unlikely that there will be a Republican replacement. The only politicians with any name recognition are the Democrats. Most people couldn't name a prominent Republican when the legislature isn't in session simply because the media only seems to bash them when they're in session or have an election coming up. Otherwise they mostly concentrate on Trump bashing. When we had a Republican governor a few years ago, Tim Pawlenty, most of the MNHTF member bashed him as a RINO which he most certainly wasn't. For a MN Republican he was quite conservative. He got us CCW. His only real fault was giving a billion of our dollars to the Vikings after opposing the new stadium as a legislator. It was a not-on-my-watch move on Pawlenty's part. The main difference between IL Democrats & MN Democrats is that IL Dems are overtly corrupt, or at least much moreso than the MN Dems. The MN Dems are passive aggressive & buy votes based on emotions & bullshit. Here's an example of Democrat perfidy: Minnesota has a Democrat led commission or board to govern every aspect of our lives, like the Minnesota Metropolitan Mosquito Control District & the Minnesota Sports Facilities Commission (MSFC). Anyway, the MSFC had to have two chair people for some reason. One was Ted Mondale, the son of the former MN senator, so it was quite obvious right there that the fix was in. The other was Michelle Kelm-Helgen who was the governor's former secretary. They each got paid $160,000 a year for essentially doing nothing, going to a few meetings every year. There was a big scandal, by MN standards at least, when it came out that Kelm-Helgen was found to have given free seats in the new Viking stadium suite to a bunch of her friends. Few records were kept so when it came to light some of those people paid a few bucks back for their seats, something like $160 each when they were valued at $1200(?) each. Anyway, Kelm-Helgen finally resigned a s a result of that scandal but not until she got her & some of her friends season tickets to every Vikings game on the 50 yard line. She made a point of saying she was sorry but apparently she wasn't sorry enough to give them back. Now she's faded into obscurity but her season tickets are still being used by her & her friends & family, actually for the first full season this year. BTW, there is now one chairwoman for the MSFC & she's part time & she gets maybe $60,000 a year. I guess you could check all the figures out to be sure that they're 100% correct but they're pretty close. Minneapolis & St. Paul seem to be on a kick of "I'm more Communist that you are. No, I'm more Communist that you are." They keep running goofy politicians who are in a contest to see how much of our money they can give away. As far a mid-sized cities, they are following as fast as they can. Rochester & St. Cloud used to be real nice cities but now they have all the crime that the Cities do. Duluth is probably leading the bunch toward full blown Communism, probably the result of the extreme Iron Range politics. The geography of MN is very nice & you have quite a range of things to choose from. There are the hills of SE MN, the great north woods, Lake Superior, 10,000 lakes, (actually there are more than 15,000), & probably the least appreciated part of the state, the prairies. Also, there are a lot of things to see & do in The Cities of course. There are a lot of good gun shows in the metro area. Look at the MWCA.org website. BTW, the in crowd uses the term "The Cities" not the Twin Cities. Good Luck OP. View Quote |
|
Thanks for all the info so far. Much appreciated. Anywhere is cheaper to live than Illinois. We just got another property tax and income and gas tax hike. Our taxes here suck. Again, thanks for the help with my questions.
I read that Rochester is slipping. How is Winona or other areas in the southeastern area? |
|
Quoted:
That kind corruption is infantile compared to Chicago. Those guys do shit in the open and nothing happens. Thanks for the response View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
MN doesn't have anything like the IL FOID. You can own whatever you like. See above for the exceptions to that. The permitting requirements are for purchasing not ownership. The Democrat Party OWNS Minnesota & will for a long time to come. The presidential vote was a fluke & a pleasant surprise. The current Democrat governor is quitting after his current term & it's extremely unlikely that there will be a Republican replacement. The only politicians with any name recognition are the Democrats. Most people couldn't name a prominent Republican when the legislature isn't in session simply because the media only seems to bash them when they're in session or have an election coming up. Otherwise they mostly concentrate on Trump bashing. When we had a Republican governor a few years ago, Tim Pawlenty, most of the MNHTF member bashed him as a RINO which he most certainly wasn't. For a MN Republican he was quite conservative. He got us CCW. His only real fault was giving a billion of our dollars to the Vikings after opposing the new stadium as a legislator. It was a not-on-my-watch move on Pawlenty's part. The main difference between IL Democrats & MN Democrats is that IL Dems are overtly corrupt, or at least much moreso than the MN Dems. The MN Dems are passive aggressive & buy votes based on emotions & bullshit. Here's an example of Democrat perfidy: Minnesota has a Democrat led commission or board to govern every aspect of our lives, like the Minnesota Metropolitan Mosquito Control District & the Minnesota Sports Facilities Commission (MSFC). Anyway, the MSFC had to have two chair people for some reason. One was Ted Mondale, the son of the former MN senator, so it was quite obvious right there that the fix was in. The other was Michelle Kelm-Helgen who was the governor's former secretary. They each got paid $160,000 a year for essentially doing nothing, going to a few meetings every year. There was a big scandal, by MN standards at least, when it came out that Kelm-Helgen was found to have given free seats in the new Viking stadium suite to a bunch of her friends. Few records were kept so when it came to light some of those people paid a few bucks back for their seats, something like $160 each when they were valued at $1200(?) each. Anyway, Kelm-Helgen finally resigned a s a result of that scandal but not until she got her & some of her friends season tickets to every Vikings game on the 50 yard line. She made a point of saying she was sorry but apparently she wasn't sorry enough to give them back. Now she's faded into obscurity but her season tickets are still being used by her & her friends & family, actually for the first full season this year. BTW, there is now one chairwoman for the MSFC & she's part time & she gets maybe $60,000 a year. I guess you could check all the figures out to be sure that they're 100% correct but they're pretty close. Minneapolis & St. Paul seem to be on a kick of "I'm more Communist that you are. No, I'm more Communist that you are." They keep running goofy politicians who are in a contest to see how much of our money they can give away. As far a mid-sized cities, they are following as fast as they can. Rochester & St. Cloud used to be real nice cities but now they have all the crime that the Cities do. Duluth is probably leading the bunch toward full blown Communism, probably the result of the extreme Iron Range politics. The geography of MN is very nice & you have quite a range of things to choose from. There are the hills of SE MN, the great north woods, Lake Superior, 10,000 lakes, (actually there are more than 15,000), & probably the least appreciated part of the state, the prairies. Also, there are a lot of things to see & do in The Cities of course. There are a lot of good gun shows in the metro area. Look at the MWCA.org website. BTW, the in crowd uses the term "The Cities" not the Twin Cities. Good Luck OP. Good luck OP. |
|
Thanks. We like it in MT a lot but it is a much further move. I practically live in WI 2 months out of the year for musky fusing tournaments. We have travelled to MN to see friends and such and looks beautiful and appears to be a good spot to consider as well. Probably going to come up for a weekend to see some places at the end of September.
|
|
If you're not a liberal and not city people, I wouldn't even consider Rochester, St. Cloud, or Duluth. While they all retain some of their smaller-town feel in different ways, and this is probably true in most states, they definitely want to follow in the paths of MSP (culturally and developmentally, in addition to politically as hardcase mentioned). Rochester and St. Cloud are much farther behind on that scale than Duluth, but they all desire to head in that direction.
There aren't many places south of the Minnesota River valley (or south of its confluence with the Mississippi) I wouldn't consider living. Winona is a nice town, along with Mankato for something slightly larger and Red Wing for something smaller. Obviously the smaller or further out you get from the Cities, the more challenging employment can become. Let us know if you decide to come up for a visit -- I'd be more than happy to be of any assistance possible, as I'm sure would plenty of the other HTF folks. |
|
Quoted:
*snip* Let us know if you decide to come up for a visit -- I'd be more than happy to be of any assistance possible, as I'm sure would plenty of the other HTF folks. View Quote Let us know if you are coming up and you want someone to show you around. MN has a lot to offer, especially on the hunting and fishing front. |
|
One area you could check out is Brainerd. Getting to be some gun culture around there. A couple good training facilities, indoor range, lots of lakes.
|
|
Thanks for all the information. Doing a lot of research online. This is a big life decision and we want to make sure we do it right. Thanks for the suggestions. Every time an area is listed I am googling the crap out of it. I will let you all know when we are coming up for a visit and you guys can feel free to give us more recommendations.
|
|
I agree Duluth is too full of hipsters and liberal handholding. That said, I do enjoy it here. Plenty of things to do along the Northshore and not too far to be out in the middle of the woods. Plenty of shooting opportunities though gunshops are a bit limited.
|
|
|
So we are going up to Wisconsin in a few weeks for a few days to look at some towns. We are stopping in LaCrosse and are probably gonna jump over to Winona in MN. We aren't making the full MN visit for a bit yet but we figured we were up there and might as well check across the border. Any other places near the border worth looking at?
|
|
Take a drive up 61 toward the Cities. You'll go through a lot of smaller towns so you won't make great time, but if the purpose of the trip is sightseeing, it's beautiful drive. I suggest that you stop at The Eagle Center in Wabasha.
Keep your eyes open for eagles as you're driving but there are a lot of turkey vultures out this year that can easily be mistaken for eagles at first glance. They won't have the white head or tail of a mature eagle but you could see some immature bald eagles too, which superficially look like turkey vultures. The last time that I was down there they Eagle Center had a golden eagle too. Sorry for the clunky website. |
|
Don't do it. Don't move here. It's not worth it. Nothing is worth living in Minnesota.
|
|
|
|
Quoted:
Don't do it. Don't move here. It's not worth it. Nothing is worth living in Minnesota. View Quote I live in the north metro (a republican county) and I don't have an issue at all. The state government does suck with the inner city democrats wanting to take away everything but that is state that has a bigger metropolitan area. As long as there is GOCRA in the state we should be fairly safe with the gun laws. I won't say completely safe as you never know. For outdoors activities Minnesota rates very well. It has something for almost anyone. Fishing, hunting, hiking, and camping are plentiful as are a bunch of other activities. |
|
Quoted:
Don't do it. Don't move here. It's not worth it. Nothing is worth living in Minnesota. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Why? You guys seem to be advancing your 2nd amendment rights. You have nice lakes and forests. I figure as long as we stay out of city we would be fine. Please clarify why we shouldn't. It would be helpful. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Don't do it. Don't move here. It's not worth it. Nothing is worth living in Minnesota. |
|
I live in the Duluth area, just outside of town. As long as you're not in the city limits it's a good place to be. Most of the B.S. liberal politics end at the city limits around here.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.