This is going to surprise many. When I was a kid, both my brother and I shot a lot (several hundred) of California ground squirrels with a Sheridan Blue Streak. What we found was that 6 pumps killed much quicker than 8 at 15 to 20 yards (many were closer).
Later on, we also observed the same effect when shooting birds with shotguns. Somehow, projectiles in the 400 to 500 ft/s range tend to kill quicker than those significantly above 600 ft/s. It is not until one gets above 1200 ft/s that things start to go the other way. These are striking velocities, not muzzle.
On another note, both my brother and I have found that where a PCP tune is most consistent in terms of velocity, is not likely where the most precision occurs. This seems to fly in the face of those who tune only for consistent velocity. My brother has remarked that he does not know how one can tune for accuracy/precision using a chronograph, for it does not tell the entire story, and it can lie to you.
That said, velocity measurements are easy to do and easy to compare. They also give one an idea on which level each "platform" lives.
BTW, from what I remember, the Sheridan Blue Streak was rated for up to eight pumps. Beyond that, you could experience leaks, and seal failure with minimal gain.