Well, I'm considering getting one of these big boys for some mid-range shooting. I've shot the Barrett M82, which is a hoot, but out of my price range. I've also found the accuracy to be below my expectations. It is probably a combination of rifle and surplus imported ammo. Anyway, I'm leaning towards the bolt guns for three reasons:
1.) Accuracy
2.) Cost
3.) I'm a lefty when it comes to rifles
I'm also partial to repeaters as opposed to single shots. But there aren't a lot of options in my price range for repeaters (about $3,000 tops minus glass.) The Barrett M95 or McBros aren't out of reach, just more than I really want to spend. I also don't think the M95 is lefty friendly at all.
Intended use: There is a monthly 50BMG match near me that I would participate in. The range is 550 yards, and 15 rounds are fired total for the match. Due to the cost of the ammo, I'm very likely to reload for it. It probably won't save any money over the SA surplus I see all the time, but I'll get match ammo out of it instead for the same price.
With those factors in mind, I've narrowed the choices down to the following:
1.) Barrett M99 variant.Considerations:
a.) Prefer the M99-1 for the slightly shorter barrel, but the 32" would be OK too.
b.) I checked the cheek weld on this weapon for a lefty, and it seemed OK. Any feedback?
c.) Ronnie Barrett is one hell of a guy! That is almost reason enough there to get the M99.
d.) Cost is quite a bit higher than the alternatives. Local shop has one for $4,300 (tan color, Bushnell scope and 80 rounds of ammo included.) I can probably get a bare bones version for around $3,000, or buy a used one for $2,600+.
e.) Not magazine fed (somewhat of a bummer.)
f.) Not very "customizable" in terms of stocks (LOP, drop, cheek rise, etc.)
2.) Blue Grass Armory ViperConsiderations:
a.) Looks very similar to a Barrett M99 to me.
b.) Available as a lefty model (bonus)
c.) Same customizing issues as the Barrett M99.
d.) $2,900 price tag isn't too bad. I've got a dealer friend, so I can probably get a better price still.
e.) Still not magazine fed
3.) State Arms Shorty with the wood stock.Considerations:
a.) Nice looking rifle! I like the look of the laminated stock, but don't really care for the tactical stock. I know that wood stocks, even laminated ones, have some environmental issues with regards to accuracy. I'm OK with that.
b.) Price is attractive at $2,300
c.) Not magazine fed
d.) Shell holder design I believe. Is this a drawback? I thought some people were "poo-pooing" the shell holder designs.
e.) Lefty version available for $100 more
4.) Safety Harbor UltraMag 50Considerations:
a.) Magazine fed! 3 or 5 rounds fed from the left side.
b.) Drops onto an AR lower receiver. Allows for customization of stock and grips. I'd probably use the new Magpul PRS stock for this application.
c.) Looks to be quite usable for a lefty
d.) Price is attractive at $1,850 for the 22" version, or $2,100 for the 29" version.
e.) Cost is misleading. Need to add cost of a lower ($90), LPK ($50) and a stock ($255 for the PRS.) That adds $400 to the cost of the weapon. 29" version now on par with the others.
f.)
5.)
Ferret50 AR15 conversion uppera.) AR conversion again, so I like the available options
b.) Not magazine fed
c.) About the same price as the UltraMag 50
d.) Lefty version available.
So those are about it. I eliminated the Serbu BFG-50 based on the appearance that it would not be very comfortable for lefty (bad cheek placement.) The McBros and Barrett M95 are outside my comfort zone in terms of cost. The Barrett M82, while an amazing weapon and fun to shoot, is far beyond my budget. Same thing goes for the EDM Windrunner (which I love!) but again, far too much capital needed.
Of these choices, I'm leaning the most towards the UltraMag-50. It seems the price/value/features relationship is almost exactly what I'm looking for. It is in my budget, is a repeater, and allows for customization of the stock and grips based on the AR lower receiver being used.
Purchase timing isn't until after SHOT show in February. I'm hoping many of these companies will be there, and I can check them out first hand. Plus, you never know when someone is going to unveil something for SHOT!
Last question could be a topic all unto itself, barrel length. How much velocity is given up with a 22" barrel vs. the 29"? Is the muzzle blast and noise from the shorter barrels a major hindrance? I was thinking the UltraMag-50 with the 22" barrel would make for a more portable package. But if too much long range capability is given up because of 7" of barrel, I'll get the longer version.
So, any comments or suggestions? Did I miss a major choice that meets the general criteria? Anyone local to Seattle with any of these that wouldn't mind a "show and tell?" Don't necessarily need to shoot it, but get some hands on the product.
Thanks.
Scott