User Panel
Posted: 10/16/2003 11:22:34 AM EDT
I went to the Memphis, TN gun show this past week. Prior to entrance we were asked to show our weapons as “cleared” and to enter the building with our pistols in a “safe mode” (slide locked back). The people at the desk inspected weapon to insure it was clear and then put a plastic strap through the action and around the slide to make gun inoperable. Also magazine were marked with stickers with one’s name on it and could be claimed at time of exit (I chose to take my mags back to car). When I holstered my Glock 27 I noticed a tight fit into my Sidearmor holster. When I was leaving, I presented my weapon to the man at the desk so he could cut the strap off. I then noticed that the buckle on the plastic strap had caused a bind when gun was holstered which caused the front site to be dislodged and fall to the floor . Back at the car, with some diligent surgery with crude instruments, I was able to re-install my front sight. Now, here is my question. Why are we required to carry our weapons unloaded to a gun show?? This is like our own back yard. If I were an anti-gunner, I would most certainly use this as ammunition by stating, “Well, those gun-nuts don’t even left themselves carry loaded weapons in there own places (gun shows) why should we allow them to carry weapons in other public places. I think its pretty hypocritical of them to demand the right to concealed carry in public, when they themselves don’t allow it on their own soil.” etc. etc. Am I missing a perfectly good reason for this practice? Is it to make the show safer? Where else would you feel safer? If a person decides to “sling lead” in this setting, he would look like Swiss cheese in a matter of seconds (I admit I wouldn’t want to be behind him). What do you think about this practice of disarmament at gun shows?
|
|
Yeah, I see the same thing. My bet is insurance. The venues probably require the promoters to provide huge policies, and the insurance companies are dictating a pile of rules before writing the policy.
Just a guess. |
|
Ummm, i guess you havent heard about all the negligent discharges that have happened at gunshows over the last couple of years. Better safe than dead. Fact is a lot of people who attend gunshows are too STUPID to carry a loaded weapon, so they had to put a stop to it. Sucks huh. -Spaceman |
|
Sad to say, but spacemanspiff is correct: some of these guys are REAL dufuses. Next time you go to a show, just look areound you and talk to people. An eyeopener.
|
|
Thats what I was thinking. If your state doesnt require you to not CC in a gunshow than you cant. But if this guy isnt a LEO you dont have to tell him your carrying plain and simple. |
|
|
I agree with all of the above. But what kind of front sight falls off with a little prompting from a plastic tie? I would suggest something a little tougher.
|
|
A few reasons.
One, as mentioned, is insurance. Another is liability of the promoter(s) and staff. It is to their advantage to take reasonable steps to avert problems, and that includes loaded firearms. Even if a person lies about carrying, the promoters and staff can say that they exercised due diligence in asking whether or not an individual was carrying. When I do door duty, at our gunshow, everyone is asked whether or not they are carrying. The only persons not temporarily disarmed are on-duty cops. Yes I have de-activated the firearms of off-duty cops, and thet was the most hassle I ever had on the job. |
|
Too many people handling too many guns to take a chance.
It's the same reason why on a cold range during cease fire NO-ONE handles any guns. |
|
Because there's always some ignorant son of a bitch who sets off a rd. I've seen dealers do it as well as customers. It's a good rule! |
|
|
ND is definatly the concern. In the last couple of years there have been three serious NDs at the big Tulsa show. One person got shot.
|
|
Speaking of which...whoohoo...its GunShow time. I would say the rule sorta makes sense since people are much more likely to be handling their guns in the show. Whether its to try out a new holster or maybe someone is thinking about a spur of the moment trade. Maybe someone asks to see the such and such mod you have done. Maybe I'm grasping at straws. |
|
|
|
||
|
IMO, because thats what you asked for, there are too many mental midgets walking around at gun shows. Gangsta wannabes, paramilitary neverweres, and just plain idiots.
Please, make them unload at the door, or I won't be able to go to anymore gun shows. (Mrs Mick doesn't want me shot by an idiot.) |
|
Thanks for your feedback. And I agree with you about the fragile nature of the front site. It is the stock site that came on the glock. I planned,even prior to this, putting some Heinie straight 8's sites on it.
L.P. |
|
Personally, I always sort of wonder about the guys who feel the need to walk around a gun show with an empty, strap-tied gun in a holster...
Seriously, I've been to 3 different gun shows in the past 10 years or so where there was a ND - one into the ceiling, one with two injuries, and one with a death. Like many of you, I've seen some of the... ummm... more questionable-looking, shall we say, folks at some of the shows. Frankly, I like the "No Loaded Weapon" policy at the shows. Sorry. |
|
Been going to gunshows for more years than I care to think and I can't ever recall a show that didn't require you to unload. Perfectly sensible rule.
|
|
And where is all this handling and unloading of loaded weapons going on at? Right there at the front door? Seems to me, its a lot more dangerous to do this, than to leave it alone in its holster and not say anything. If your there to sell something, it should be unloaded anyway and yes, checked at the door. There no reason the pistol in my holster is coming out short of some life threatening thing, so whats it matter? It hasnt gone off by itself yet.
|
|
I love going to gun shows, but at the same time I look and see more and more mental midgets.
I'm more than OK with the rule. |
|
The firearm is first pointed in a safe direction, and then the mag is extracted. Next, the live round is ejected. With me watching like a hawk at each step. This is done by the owner, not me. Presumably, they are more familiar with unloading their own firearm than I am. Nothing unsafe about the procedure.
I'm sure that is true for you, but I have seen a significant number of other people who are not quite so self-disciplined. Given the stakes, it is unfortunately necessary to arrange things so that the lowest common denominator is taken care of. I'm sure the Antis would secretly love for there to be a fatal ND at our (or any) show, so as to make it easier to close 'em all down. |
||
|
I'm afraid I have to agree that the "bozo factor" is way too high at most gun shows. Last thing I want to do is see someone injured because someone lacks trigger finger discipline when checking out the fit of a holster.
|
|
why did you feel that was necessary? |
|
|
I can't tell how many times I've been to shows and got behind people going down the aisle who can't bathe before they go out in public. Make these idiots unload I say. If you read this and your one of those people, then take a f**king bath next time.
|
|
In the same vein, your giving the anti's ammo by saying that you dont trust people to carry loaded guns at the shows. So if the GUN people dont trust gun people to have loaded weapons, how can the rest of the country? Yup, real good message. As for ND's, most of the few I've heard of came from or behind dealers tables. |
|
|
Primarily out of fairness to the other, non-leo citizens who were within earshot. I considered it to be the path of least resistance to disarm the rare off-duty LEO and not to have to face the far more numerous non-LEOS who I was compelled to disarm. If they didn't wish to disarm, they could simply leave the premises. No harm, no foul. |
||
|
Your point is counterbalanced by the image of gun people policing themselves in the interest of safety. There are valid reasons to disarm which have nothing to do with trusting/distrusting CCW gunowners. For example, gunshows, due to space constraints, tend to be crowded affairs. Lots of people coming and going and bumping into one another. Not at all like most public venues where CCW goes on. Disarming people at gunshows may be heard of by a few; a fatal (or even a non-fatal) ND will be heard of by many. Given that one MUST choose between the leave armed/disarm alternatives, which do you think does the least harm to gunowners' image in the long run? Keep in mind that the decision to disarm is made by the renters/suppliers of the venue in our case, not by our organization. Were it up to us alone, however, the decision might well be the same, given liability issues. On balance, I'd rather disarm, with that decision's baggage, than have an ND with its far greater baggage. YMMV. |
||
|
VERY WELL-SAID, raf! Even down here in the very-pro-gun Deep South, the local news outlets got weeks of mileage out of each of the last two gun show NDs I mentioned earlier. (And yes, the "Brady Bunch" dispatched someone down here to make sure that happened!) |
|
|
No kidding. I've run into the foulest smelling people at gunshows. |
|
|
Amen. |
|
|
A little off subject, but what do you do if the guy standing beside you at a table pops off a round? What if after the first round the slide is not locked back, or he is holding a revolver? What if he just stands there with a dumb look on his face? WHAT IF HE JUST SHOT SOMEBODY? Do you tackle him? Conk him on the head? Worse? Or just make sure the po-po knows it was him when they come running over? |
|
I've never been right next to where the "event" occurred, but the reaction of the crowd to a round going off in a gun show was identical in all three cases that I have witnessed: Big crowd, a lot of low, constant noise, a lot of movement... BANG! Absolute silence & stillness (except of course the immediate vicinity of the event, in the two cases where someone was actually hit) - nobody wanted to move or say anything. It was really eerie... |
|
|
most of the people i see at gunshows i wouldnt even want on the next lane at the range.
you guys wonder why a lot of gun dealers are such pricks...its because they deal with gun show people every weekend. |
|
That sucks to hear about your front sight falling off. The good news is that at least you found out about the problem with your sight before it fell off when you needed it. The zip tie should not have posed a problem for your sight. My pistol gets zip tied at every show and I have never had a problem.
I think everyone else summed it up best by saying that the average gun show attendee may not be trained well enough to handle a loaded firarm in confined areas. I know that some folks take their firearms to be worked on and if were a vendor that last thing I would want is someone clearing their weapon in front of me and my customers. I go to a very large public range almost every weekend and about 80% of the folks there need some serious training and could not even tell me what the first rule of firearms safety is or how to field strip thier weapon. I find myself working with at least 4 or 5 different tables trying to show folks how to use thier weapons safely. In fact, I have contemplated not going back to the public range due to safety concerns. Unfortunately, firearms training just is not a priority for many gun owners. I think that this lack of training is the cause for many of the "accidents" that we read about in the paper and further fuel the ignorance about firearms in the masses. I don't have a problem clearing my weapon at the shows, it's a public event and you have to respect the right of the folks running it to maintain this policy. All that being said, I do have some friends who will not attend a gun show because the are not allowed to carry a loaded pistol. |
|
At gunshows,somtimes you wonder if the bus from the"Group Home for Jerry's Boy's"didnt pull up outside and unload it's cargo of droolers,the driver of the bus hand"his" boys each $5.00,and say"I'll be back to pick you up at 5 kids.Have a nice day at the show".Seems like a good way to get cheap baby-sitting.Cheaper even than dropping them off at the mall,where they would bother the Liberals,and their children.I have met some of the absolute dumbest,in-bred,no-reading,non-bathing,fingerfucking shit for brained,people that can exist in the free world at funshows.Also I have met some of the most helpful,informed and intelegent people that do exist,at gunshows.The good people keep you going back,as well as the love of firearms and what they represent in a free society.Yes gun dealers can be pricks at times,but it's the company they are forced to keep and the bullshit that goes with the job.
|
|
I've been to lots of shows, but saw only one ND. If I remember correctly, it was a .22.
I don't mind the "empty your guns" routine at the front door. I like seeing that jar of bullets they keep that supposedly came from "unloaded" guns. There are way too many idiots at gun shows, and everyone is handling a gun, so in terms of safety they should all be unloaded and banded. No one complains at the range when all guns must be put down. As for those guys that won't go to gun shows because they can't carry loaded - I say pick a better battle. |
|
..........gun shows suck.......but.....it was great to get those center industries mags for $12.......and the fal handguards for $5......so......whatever........
|
|
The big issue with the NDs and unloading at shows is that people will want to trade, sell, buy holsters, try on that Tactical vest, whatever; as they jam the pistol in or check it out they have a good chance of an ND. Simple; there is a high probability of handling. All of the NDs I have heard of came from holster fitting or buyers handling a weapon.
As far as the Anti's and "They don't trust themselves in the show", the answer is "You provide armed, uniformed security at *every* establishment, and following me on the streets, and I'll go unarmed". |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.