Quoted: My research into this subject showed the "Winchester" safe is actually made by Granit Security in Ft Worth, TX.
A dealer I talked to, who carries another brand, told me he was most impressed by Granit Secutiry of all the safes he had seen. He couldn't get them as his boss liked the deal he got from another company. This same guy told me the test he witnessed showed the exterior hinge design of the Granit Security (Winchester) is BETTER against fire damage than the ones with interior hinges. Interesting that the test he saw differed so much from the one described above.
I'm a little suspicious of "They did their normal 10 minute ramp up from ambient temp to 1200 degrees, and after 15 minutes the Winchester safe was on fire. The metal and everything." Metal doesn't burn at 1200 degrees, at least it didn't when I was an arson investigator. But then I'm sure Liberty wouldn't be at all biased and would be completely fair in their presentation, wouldn't they?
I ordered a Granit Secutiry 72X40X27 from Sam's Club. It was $1399 delivered to their store and they put it on a trailer for me. I rented a fork lift for $85 and moved the 1190 lb safe from the trailer into my garage, which then got bricked up into a shop. My contractor bolted the safe to the slab after it was in place.
YMMV!
|
You're right DaveT, I have a vested interest in spewing maliciously false info. BTW, is the Winchester safe 100% steel or metal door? How about the seal around the inside of the door? Would combustible contents inside give the illusion of the door being on fire? How about the rubber seal igniting from inside and around the entire door? That might also provide an illusion of the metal burning.
I'm sure Granit would also have a vested interest in providing 100% accurate information about it's competitors, hmm??
BTW, safes are like flavors at Baskin Robbins. They will all do a similar job in making you fat, but you choose one I choose another.
It just so happened that Liberty had Winchester, Sentry, and another "off" brand there to test.
As I stated the FIRST time, I bought from an independent vendor, who ALSO SOLD BOTH THE OTHER BRANDS......it would NOT have been in HER best interest to misrepresent what she saw, now would it? Especially since she thought I might buy the less expensive thought top of the line for Sentry safe.
This sounds like the typical GM vs. Ford, 9mm vs 45 argument.
BTW, the fact does not change that BOTH safes WINCHESTER AND LIBERTY were standing side by side in the same furnace AND the Winchester interior was devastated. The Liberty safe was intact with the rubber seals all melted and paper still usable.
Enjoy your safe, I hope you never have to find out if it works, as I hope mine never gets used except for theft protection.