Bought a ruger redhawk long ago, due to frame design I do not like it. With some of today's versions it might be better, but it has a regular grip frame instead of the post style the sp101, gp100, and super redhawk have.
I now own a super redhawk, happy with it. Not a great trigger but not too shabby in my opinion and being it is new production I don't worry about it very much.
Yeah the pre-lock s&w stuff is awesome but I halfway wonder about investment value vs. using it. Never had an issue with it.
I like the ruger single actions, only had super blackhawks but would consider vaquero or bisley as well if I ran into em.
Everyone has to decide what they expect or want.
The weight of the super redhawk, I got a toklat so 5 inch or so barrel, winds up working for me. The toklat is a 454 casull but I consider mine much more of a 45 colt than 454 casull cause that is what I enjoy shooting in it more. Working on getting 454 casull reloading stuff and will play with it as well. Never felt like cutting down a factory 44mag super redhawk due to cost and timeframe. Toklat was bought day I ran into it in a store.
And being the grip design is the post type, I like the grip a lot more than what my ruger redhawk had a couple decades ago.