Quote History Quoted:
Well as others have mentioned, it's just a bit too tight and doesn't have that positive lock up. Most 1-piece kydex and molded holsters are locking the pistol in around the trigger guard. That's where most of the retention should come from IMO.
On the G-Code and Blade-Techs that I've tried, the slide lock is coming in contact with the holster before it should.
I'm sure there are low cut holsters out there that work fine, but I would prefer to have something purpose built for the Gen5. A holster is not something I want half assed. I'd be even more nervous if I was carrying a Sig, but still!
There is a reason Bianchi and Safariland have both announced they are working on Gen 5 specific offerings.
View Quote
I am carrying a blade tech IWB holster right now that is retaining my gen 5 19 perfectly. Same goes for my blade tech IWB light bearing holster, but that indexes off the light. Obviously my Raven Vanguard 2 works fine with it. All of my Safariland ALS holsters work with it.
As to the part I highlighted in red, this makes zero sense. My slide hits my holster before anything else--is that somehow a problem? The previous slide locks always hit the holsters before lock, too. That's a huge reason why all of mine look so terrible finish wise.
If you want to buy a "purpose build for the gen 5" holster, just say that. Don't claim that all other holsters don't work when that just isn't true.
Part in yellow: everyone is making "gen 5 specific offerings." That's how they make money. Doesn't mean their existing stuff doesn't work.