Seems quite often on this board when someone asks a question, people who have niether held or shot the weapon in question come out of the woodwork to offer their opinions. Also, there's alot of people out there who will tell you that they heard this or that about something, when they don't offer any firsthand knowledge. Not sure how much their opinion is worth- Maybe they are just boosting their number of posts or maybe they just like to see thier name on a board. In either case, lack of first hand knowledge is a real detriment to accurate opinions.
For the record, I own a carbon 15, among many other AR variants and even an M16. The carbon 15, in my first-hand opinion is a great light rifle. It handles surprisingly well and weighs nothing. It would be a great option for a light-weight AR variant. If you can find the receiver only for sale. There may be other building issues- i.e. barrel and handguard installation, that may have to be done at the factory.
Also, FWIW, the carbon 15 was produced initially by another company before Bushmaster acquired it. Some of the bum reviews and second handers don't acknowledge that Bush has changed things for the better.