I'd probably take the CQ/T [B)]
Hahaha, nah, c'mon, you all know my answer. I wouldnt disagree with a thing Lumpster said. But I still preffer the ability to use the gun even beyond where it may be useful, and appreciate the increased target ID ability the magnification gives me at all ranges (not just extended ranges).
When it comes down to having just one, I would try to pick the one that does very many (common and uncommon) things very well than one that does most (common) things very well. Especially when the one that does more gives up very little to the one that does less.
If cost is a factor, and it usually is, the Aimpoint in no way shape or form should be considered a step down. It isnt. Both are steps up from most other optics and all iron sights, but they are just steps up different stairways.