At 1x with the 14mm objective lens you have a 14mm exit pupil. (14mm divided by one power equals 14mm). Your eye can only use 5 to 7mm in darkness let alone in good light. At 1x the 14mm exit pupil makes your eye alignment very non critical. At 3x you get 14/3=4.67mm exit pupil.
|
I was comparing the scope side by side with a TA31, TA11, Eotech 551 and Reflex. I've had a chance to evaluate the Aimpoint as well; but not side by side with the CQT.
4.67mm may seem great when examining a single scope but when you are comparing it to a TA11 with 10mm exit pupil at 3.5x, a TA31 with 8mm exit pupil at 4x, or two CQB sights that have unlimited eye-relief and are parallax-free, the soda straw analogy seems pretty apt.
Also, as you noted, since your eye can only use so much exit pupil, the only place the CQT shows an advantage (1x), the advantage wasn't noticeable to me (probably because all three scopes were showing my eye the max it could use). The only thing noticeable was that the CQT got worse as magnification increased and the others (already magnified) stayed the same.
I'll be the first to say that I didn't get to play with the CQT half as much as I'd need to make a truly informed opinion. None of the sights were mine and I was limited to about an hour with all of them; but the CQT would have been my 4th choice out of the 5 sights.