User Panel
Posted: 9/13/2013 2:56:33 PM EDT
[Last Edit: BushBoar]
So I've been on the forum long enough to know that nothing with an A2 upper will ever really be "accepted" on the retro forum (I have an early 604,late 603 and an XM177 clone so I understand why). The A2 photo thread we have is cool but for me there is just too much really modern stuff ( magpul etc.) . In my mind there is a lot of "vintage" A2 material out there (Desert Storm era A2's, late 80's gov't carbines, 723's 733's 727's etc.). So my question is really for the mod's ... would a "vintage A2 " photo thread be in order on this forum , I know the retro word really means A1 to most but maybe vintage fits guys like me who clone their desert storm etc. guns from the past. Input please.... Michael
|
|
|
Originally Posted By weath017:
So I've been on the forum long enough to know that nothing with an A2 upper will ever really be "accepted" on the retro forum (I have an early 604,late 603 and an XM177 clone so I understand why). The A2 photo thread we have is cool but for me there is just too much really modern stuff ( magpul etc.) . In my mind there is a lot of "vintage" A2 material out there (Desert Storm era A2's, late 80's gov't carbines, 723's 733's 727's etc.). So my question is really for the mod's ... would a "vintage A2 " photo thread be in order on this forum , I know the retro word really means A1 to most but maybe vintage fits guys like me who clone their desert storm etc. guns from the past. Input please.... Michael View Quote +1 for "vintage" A2 photo thread |
|
|
Get one started and I'll tack it.
|
|
Suos Cultores Scientia Coronat
"But it does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg." - Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia, 1782 |
|
RIP MSgt Adam F. "Benji" Benjamin (EOD) KIA Helmand Prov 18 Aug 2009 Semper Fi bro' and save me a seat.
Thanks SDboy for the membership. |
|
|
Originally Posted By JJREA:
But yeah, I've always been a little sore that they don't just allow us in the retro forum. I mean it's rare you even see a car from the late 80's early 90's on the road. But they want their forum to stay "Vietnam Era" I guess. And not be tainted with much less "interesting" times. As I've said before, us A2 guys are the red headed step child of Arfcom. View Quote Being the fence sitter that I am (I post in "regular" AR Discussions, Retro, and the A2 Forum ), I understand why Retro-land wanted to expel us. The only thing that bothers me sometimes is that the A2 Forum has become kind of a backwater "dumping ground" for franken-guns of all sorts with A2 uppers. But hey, the rules aren't mine to make. I do like the historical threads, though, and wish there was more traffic in here. I definitely approve of this thread, though! Gonna have to go get some pictures of my A2! ~Augee |
|
|
I mainly hang out in the retro forum but i'd love to see some vintage A2 sneaking in :)
BTW nice rifles everyone. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Augee:
Being the fence sitter that I am (I post in "regular" AR Discussions, Retro, and the A2 Forum ), I understand why Retro-land wanted to expel us. The only thing that bothers me sometimes is that the A2 Forum has become kind of a backwater "dumping ground" for franken-guns of all sorts with A2 uppers. But hey, the rules aren't mine to make. I do like the historical threads, though, and wish there was more traffic in here. I definitely approve of this thread, though! Gonna have to go get some pictures of my A2! ~Augee View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Augee:
Originally Posted By JJREA:
But yeah, I've always been a little sore that they don't just allow us in the retro forum. I mean it's rare you even see a car from the late 80's early 90's on the road. But they want their forum to stay "Vietnam Era" I guess. And not be tainted with much less "interesting" times. As I've said before, us A2 guys are the red headed step child of Arfcom. Being the fence sitter that I am (I post in "regular" AR Discussions, Retro, and the A2 Forum ), I understand why Retro-land wanted to expel us. The only thing that bothers me sometimes is that the A2 Forum has become kind of a backwater "dumping ground" for franken-guns of all sorts with A2 uppers. But hey, the rules aren't mine to make. I do like the historical threads, though, and wish there was more traffic in here. I definitely approve of this thread, though! Gonna have to go get some pictures of my A2! ~Augee Not sure why (responding to the red part). I would say that the people that are into A2's, that wanted to be part of the Retro forum, are into the "retro" aspect of A2's. If someone wants to post about their tacticool A2, they can just participate in the AR discussions. Sure' they'll get the, get a flat top comment from all the "experts", but there are some guys that have some good carry handled AR's of more modern set up. I think I particularly remember Edwin07 (not sure if it's his name exactly) have a nice pic of a carry handled set up with an ACOG on the handle. Anyways..... My point is, the weapons used in desert storm are definitely not 60's vintage, but the are pretty much looked down on in AR discussions. And it's all about the latest and greatest there. |
|
|
Originally Posted By JJREA:
Not sure why (responding to the red part). I would say that the people that are into A2's, that wanted to be part of the Retro forum, are into the "retro" aspect of A2's. If someone wants to post about their tacticool A2, they can just participate in the AR discussions. Sure' they'll get the, get a flat top comment from all the "experts", but there are some guys that have some good carry handled AR's of more modern set up. I think I particularly remember Edwin07 (not sure if it's his name exactly) have a nice pic of a carry handled set up with an ACOG on the handle. Anyways..... My point is, the weapons used in desert storm are definitely not 60's vintage, but the are pretty much looked down on in AR discussions. And it's all about the latest and greatest there. View Quote The arguments made were that the A2 was still in widespread current service - neverminding the 601s, 602s, and 604s still floating around in AF armories stateside, the fact that the A2 was still being deployed overseas to combat zones, albeit in a support role, to some, disqualified it as "Retro." The other big one was the concern about "slippage." That allowing the A2 into the Retro forum would introduce further arguments that early M4s and M16A4s should be allowed in "Retro," because they were not "the latest and greatest." I did not personally agree, and believed, and still believe that discussion of "historical" A2s in proper context should be allowed in the Retro Forum, but in the end, it wasn't my decision to make. To be fair, I think that the mods had a difficult decision in terms of "where do you place the cut off?" Incidentally, I and some others have then suggested that threads like the "1993 somalia" thread would be more appropriately placed in the A2 Forum, but once again, it's not my decision to make. I suppose in some sense, the A2 doesn't have the "romance" of a major conflict like Vietnam, the closest thing is the Gulf War, which has been overshadowed to some extent by GWOT in the social zeitgeist. I can only think, or perhaps hope, however, that the A2 Forum will one day grow to be a comparable place to the Retro Forum as times goes on. I remember, as I'm sure you still do, when the Retro Forum was awash in franken-builds, black A2 lowers and C7 uppers with 16" carbine barrels, the difference between a 603 and 604 upper was not in the common consciousness, it took a while for it to become what many now see as a place of historical study and such close "clones." And we do have some good, historical threads on here once in a while, the C7/8 thread is still an excellent collection of knowledge about a lesser known variant, and the braceman lowers and close clones are making a good showing and always draw good comments. I swear, I'll post pictures of my A2 soon! ~Augee |
|
|
I don't blame the mods at all. It was apparent that there were certain retro forum goers that really didn't like the addition of A2 threads. Even the historical ones. If my recollection is correct. Seemed like most were on the fence or neutral and there were a few more vocal ones about it. Again, just going by memory.
Like you said, not our decision. I was going to say the opposite of what you said, but as my Mom says, "My crystal ball is broken". I was going to say I'd be surprised if it picks up in here. Ever. For some reason I just don't see it happening. But I could be wrong. Maybe in 5 years or so there will be more vets or something that carried an A2 and want to build one up again. Whether they be from late 80's or 90's or even guys from the GWOT that had them. I remember seeing a lot of Marines with them early on. And then there are the support people that might have handled them quite a bit. Or even in boot camp. Etc. Etc. Who knows. Doesn't really matter. Just something to talk about I guess. Thanks for keeping it interesting. I have mine up and getting ready to clean up good and take pics too. And then I think I'll shoot it. Whatever happened to Quib? He'd be all over this. Maybe. I remember he had a few good 20" A2 threads. I think he had some experience with them in the military. I think he's more my age. Desert storm era. My recollection is he served there. Or at least during it. |
|
|
Like I said - it might be wishful thinking more than anything else.
My M16A2 build is not fully "period correct," though. I'm using a crush washer instead of peel washers. This should be remedied soon when I get over my laziness, though. ~Augee |
|
|
Changed title and tacked. Discussion is ok but please don't derail the pic thread.
Thanks!
|
|
Suos Cultores Scientia Coronat
"But it does me no injury for my neighbour to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg." - Thomas Jefferson, Notes on the State of Virginia, 1782 |
"I will murder you and make a poncho out of your skin!" DK-Prof
|
Love those shiny hand guards !
|
|
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted By weath017:
I know the retro word really means A1 to most but maybe vintage fits guys like me who clone their desert storm etc. guns from the past. Input please.... Michael View Quote As a guy who started out in the military with an A1 and who has been here for a number of years, I am still amazed by what I see as a mindset from some posters that any iron sight A1 or A2 is at best a novel antique. I remember back then it was the short barrel stuff with a collapsible stock that was different or weird, because it was mainly a throw-back to limited run Viet Nam era variants I guess that the rise of modern tech, collapsible stocks, rail systems etc has been around long enough that the younger guys on this board know of nothing else. |
|
*post contains personal opinion only and should not be considered information released in an official capacity*
0110001101101100011010010110001101101011 |
Originally Posted By Augee:
As promised, photos of my M16A2 clone: http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/951F1121-88E2-4A6B-9454-02E41C11F152-12171-00000B4E5A02D686_zps1de82b51.jpg http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/3BEA0D0A-8803-4828-8EC1-700186404000-12171-00000B4E69447695_zps5c922991.jpg http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/C6FC1670-670D-4EF5-A219-50564F00AB84-12171-00000B4E7B9A4640_zps1d3565a2.jpg Rifle is all Colt, minus the lower receiver/LPK which is a NoDak Spud NDS-A1 lower receiver. Colt "C M" markings on the upper: http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/DC310223-65CB-419B-AA2D-D8860E6DEADA-12171-00000B4E5F494165_zps06ff297d.jpg It's hard to see here, but the proper barrel markings: http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/0E6565D1-362C-403B-9CD5-BE9D2DA1C666-12171-00000B4E641A131B_zpsc0fcd334.jpg Also visible, and much more clearly is the totally, heinously, and terribly wrong crush washer that I need to replace with a peel washer. Please accept my apologies. The sling is a standard USGI silent sling installed with a USGI top sling adapter, using the wire loop for the FSB and the strap for the stock. I'm considering replacing the stock adapter with the simpler, more common, and frankly, more functional 550 cord and 100MPH tape "adapter." Front loop: http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/1EC26A05-A2A4-407E-93D3-706A2499AC97-12171-00000B4E7680D54B_zps61eed52e.jpg Stock adapter, also visible is the blue paint pen rack number, "132": http://i1239.photobucket.com/albums/ff502/augeekim/126BFCF8-FB83-4A94-B7A6-AB6C9E177056-12171-00000B4E70E84E8B_zps520c1aa1.jpg I eventually would like to have Ident or someone similar engrave the NDS-A1 lower receiver as an early Colt M16A1, marked both "AR15" and "M16A1," then use a stamp kit and overstamp the "1" in "M16A1" with a crooked "2," and "X" out the "AUTO" marking and stamp "BURST" as well as engraving the right side selector markings, and stamp "A N A D" rebuild markings on the right side of the mag well so the whole rifle will look like an Army rebuild. The only other change to be made besides the peel washer is to find an ANAD rebuild-style selector/safety with the raised "notch" to install in place of the Colt "no tick" selector that's currently installed. She may be old-school, but she's still a great rifle and a lot of fun to shoot, and I still break in beginners on her, and she gets fired more than my M16A4 and XM16E1 clone combined, and is my current "iron sights trainer" mule that I shoot with when I want to return to the basics and fundamentals and shoot open sights, which I cycle through my training routines. Run and gun and drills are all well and good, but it's important to return to the fundamentals once in a while, and the A2 is usually what I do it with! ~Augee View Quote question : wouldn't a lock washer be more correct than a crush washer ? my FN barrel came with a lock washer . just wondered . |
|
|
"Lock" style washers were used in the A1 series rifles ( the birdcage flash hider did not need to be exactly timed) the peel washer was used on the A2 series because the flashider did need to be timed, the crush washer was brought out because the peel washer was a raging pain in the a$$ to deal with. I have seen crush washers used on late a2's and most a4's but to me the peel washer is the iconic look for the A2. Michael
|
|
|
I forgot to say, that is really nice Augee!!
|
|
|
|
moved
|
|
"Is the Poop Deck really what I think it is?" - Homer Simpson
"A man can't just sit around" - Larry Walters. 1982 |
Oooh yeah!!!
|
|
|
Well to better put it, I should be called the A2/A3 forum. Remember A3's
|
|
|
Love this thread, and the A2 forum as well. I was in the USAF from 2003-2011, and can indeed confirm that many of the M16 A2's I held had the "1" stamped over by a "2". I converted a post ban Armalite M15 A2 to a close A1 but sold it a few years ago . After Sandy Hook I realized I needed to get off my ass and get another one before they get banned. Fortunately, no ban was enacted and the panic started to subside, so I could start collecting reasonably priced parts. I'll post some pics of my rifle here probably this weekend, or maybe Friday night. But here are some specs:
Anderson Mfg lower DPMS LPK CMMG BCG DPMS gas tube Keyhole "F" upper DPMS A2 style HBAR mil spec used handguards and stock set mil spec new flash hider, delta ring assy, ejection port cover, and FA I is a nice shooter and pretty close to most of the A2's I handled during my USAF time. I even have a surplus mag that says "For Government and law enforcement use only" to go with it. |
|
|
Thank you for your service and looking forward to seeing your rifle!
|
|
|
|
She's purdy! Post away with the other one. I'm not a mod around here, but this forum needs all the posting it can get. If it has a2 sights than there's no reason not to post it here.
|
|
|
|
Nice. That will make some people's brain hurt. LOL.
|
|
|
Wouldn't the carbine be a 6520?
|
|
|
As soon as the form 1 arrives it will be 14.5 and that will be the difference. Michael
|
|
|
Supposed to get my my new FN A2 barrel and stripped upper sometime next week to mate with my Mega Lower. I do need to find a FN BCG and surplus A2 hand guards.
|
|
Mark it Zero!!
|
Plays well with self, and cleverly disguised as a responsible adult.
|
If U can't Truck It F!@k It!
|
"Well I'll just dump this here in GD and let the ball roll. " Go with God Jeff.
|
Originally Posted By imdBman: 1989 Camp Pendletonhttp://i275.photobucket.com/albums/jj290/imdbman65/CampPendleton90wM203.jpg View Quote |
|
"Well I'll just dump this here in GD and let the ball roll. " Go with God Jeff.
|
Originally Posted By Madcap72:
Also camp Pendleton! https://scontent-b-sea.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-frc3/s720x720/564808_10151772853130346_602581833_n.jpg Try to guess the year! View Quote My guess would be '85 or '86 |
|
|
I guess 87-90. Speednlace boots showed up after 87.
My pic was during a patrol. |
|
If U can't Truck It F!@k It!
|
Originally Posted By Madcap72:
Also camp Pendleton! https://scontent-b-sea.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-frc3/s720x720/564808_10151772853130346_602581833_n.jpg Try to guess the year! View Quote Reminds me of the "Shelf" at MCT/SOI. Late 80's, early 90's. |
|
|
91 ??????
|
|
|
|
Nice. I thought those Flak Jackets were heavy back then. I hated them. Very light compared to the body armor carried today.
|
|
If U can't Truck It F!@k It!
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.