Quoted:
Bolt carriers are interchangeable.
Bolts are not.
View Quote
I disagree.
On an AR, the headspace is determined by the fit of the bolt in the barrel extension. There is no way to adjust headspace short of replacing the bolt.
View Quote
True.
And he is right, each manufacturer sets their own tolerances for each part
View Quote
They do? Most AR manufacturers dont even MAKE bolts or barrel extensions. They buy them. Typically from the same few manufacturers.
The parts are made to an industry spec, and they are assembled and headspaced to an industry spec.
so their their bolts will usually work with their barrels
View Quote
An in-spec barrel *should* headspace fine with ANY manufacturers bolt, and vice versa.... since they dont make bolts.
... but mixing manufacturers creates a potential for "stacking tolerances" that can add up to excessive headspace and blown-up receivers.
View Quote
It's not mixing manufacturers that *could* cause this. Its mixing out of spec, or worn parts with other out-of-spec, or worn parts that *could* cause a headspace issue.
Now, you may be lucky (do ya feel lucky?) and a bolt from (B) may fit a barrel from (A) to give you correct headspace. But you should check it before you shoot, and if it's excessive, you have to keep buying replacement bolts until you find one that fits.
View Quote
Good advice.
Or you could just buy a new bolt with each barrel, which is what I do.
View Quote
Mee too! But I didn't always, and never had an issue. If I was buying a used barrel, and a used bolt, I would definitely check it... and it never hurts to check ANY rifle you assemble or use.....
But the bottom line is, they CAN be swapped, and different manufacturers makes no difference. All that matters is the parts used are in spec, and not worn..... and therefore, that they headspace properly.