User Panel
One of us is sorely lacking in history, and I think it is you. But, independently, I will look into whether the Muslims of Yugoslavia provoked the response of the Serbs after the disunification in the 1990s though aggression and terrorism, and whether they had it coming in the name of Serbian nationalism. |
|||
|
Bullshit! There's a line that can be crossed and I don't give a rats ass if it's a person, a town, a state, a country or a fucking continent, the atrocity must be stopped. If another nation has the ability to stop it , then they must and we did. End of story. Where the fuck did you get the idea that what he was doing was his own damn business? You win the award for most screwed up post I have ever read. And that ain't a good thing. |
|
|
So we should be in Sudan right now? Have you written your congressman? |
||
|
I don't know.... my head hurts |
|
|
When speaking in absolutes, you open yourself to dangerous situations. The stopping of genocide as a moral imperative is unquestioned. The question becomes to we impose morality on others in the form of national policy? If we, as a country, must stop all genocide when it happens, then we might as well PCS all our soldiers to staging bases in Africa because that is where the fighting is. I propose, as have others (despite the labeling of 88s and whatnot), that our military should be used when our country and our citizens are threatened. The question of the thread then becomes, was milosovic (or more to the point, his actions) posing a threat to the United States? I say, "No." |
||
|
So...the muslims in any given nation can attack their neighbors, and when the neighbors defend themselves "they must be stopped"? Who appointed you to be Globo Cop? You are a very good Dhimmi |
||
|
It's a stupid question. There is no "proof" of morals, it's not a scientific theory or law.... Provide me proof that rape is wrong, or stealing, or tax evasion..... It's a dumb question asked by a dumb person.... |
||
|
You're going to run out of Soldiers and Marines with that plan friend. Talk about an Empire. |
||
|
So, all the Christians on this board are dumb? |
|
|
No, just people who try to equate morality with concepts like proof and evidence. There is no "proof" or "evidence" when it comes to what is morally right and wrong.... You are putting forth an untestable opinion, and demanding people to provide proof and evidence to show your opinion as wrong. There are three views of morality, your view, my view and societies view. I might think that bank robbing is ok, since no one gets hurt, no one loses their own money, and the govt. can always print more, but society has deemed bank robbery as wrong and punishes offenders accordingly. For the Nietzche fans, we join into a social contract with society, society allows us to live in that society and to interact with other people, enjoy certain benefits, etc. in exchange we agree to live by that unwritten contract. Violating that contract empowers society to punish the violaters. Society feels that genocide is wrong, and is a part of that social contract. When a leader (such as Hitler, or Milosevic) violates the social contract, they are punished when they fall from power and a dominant power has the ability to carry out the punishment. So why was Milosevic's actions wrong? Because we said so. |
||
|
If I had to choose between killing 10,000 random Chinese people, which would constitute a genocide, or allowing the entire Earth's population to die, I would choose the 10,000 Chinese people. I feel that would be the right decision in that hypothetical example. You would be required by your opinion to allow the entire population of the Earth to die. I feel that would be the wrong choice for all involved. What do you think? |
|
|
He should have died in a public square huh? |
|
|
Christians have no proof of their morality? I think all here would disagree, and I don't feel they are dumb for seeing their evidence as proof. Where are you getting your take on Nietzsche from? |
|
|
Not exactly what I meant... |
||
|
You don't defend yourself by butchering old men, women and children. Based upon yours, and other's arguments, 9/11 was justified because "anything goes" when you are defending yourself from an enemy. |
|||
|
I am not taking a position necessarily. I just think that the popular view is only one sided (ie the reports from refugees about tens and even hundreds of thousands of muslims murdered when the real number is in the thousands). Things might look different to us in the future after six hundred years of squabbling with muslims in our midst. In contrast to Hitler and the holocaust, the Serbs seemed to want to drive the muslims out and treat the resisters with an iron fist, something that Hitler did not pursue. Hitler was culling subhumans, from what I have read the Serbs wanted peace in their borders which history has shown is not realistic with a significant muslim population. |
||||
|
bright idea of the day: hey guys, why don't we just kill off all of the African-Americans since they are responsible for a clear majority of the crime and social distress in the US . Doesn't matter if it is just the men, let's just kill the women and children too so they won't breed. After all, everywhere Africans have been a sizable portion of the population there has been genocide,murder,rape, and a slew of other crimes. |
|||||
|
which ones: 1) Those that justify genocide. 2) Those that aren't total sociopaths. ? |
|
|
You are slowly catching on. I am sure there are places in the world where George W Bush would be arrested, tried and shot as soon as he stepped off the plane. |
|
|
hold onto hope his trial could take forever. |
||
|
Among other things, Slobo violated the laws of war and was a war criminal. |
|
|
The overwhelming majority of blacks are Christians. Black Christian ministers/priests don't call for the destruction of the West. Blacks are stomping some Islamo-facist guts as we post. |
|
|
This might very well be the best post I've read on ARFCOM. The problem is that all of the idiots that have already bought into the leftwing lie about this will refuse to believe the truth. |
|
|
Not really. Many of the former Warsaw pact communist parties took a swerve towards facsism after the wall came down. As Austin Bay puts it: "He epitomized the move from “red to brown” in eastern Europe– moving from Communist to ultra-nationalist fascist as the Cold War ended." Ultra-nationalism provided a handy tool to exploit the sentiments of the people and keep themselves in power. |
|
|
Are there any good books about this whole situation that aren't left wing distortions?
|
|
Trying to find out who's side I'm on? |
||
|
What "Euros"?? The British, Dutch, and Danes who all have troops in Iraq and joined the war when Bush asked? Who have troops in Bosnia and Kosovo, and supported the U.S. action there? Those "Euros"? All of the ones, like the Poles, Bulgarians, etc - who are becoming really strong U.S. allies? Please be specific when bashing "Euros" - and vent your anger appropriately on the French and Germans and their ilk ... otherwise I'll start referring to Mexicans and Candians as "those swarthy Americans" and those "french-speaking Americans" respectively Sorry pet peeve. Europe is just a word on a map - there is no "Europe" in any real sense of the word. European countries like Norway and Portugal are more different from one another than Vermont and Mexico. |
|
|
Really makes that whole "EU" thing seem like a bad idea, huh? |
|
|
Just because the desire to eliminate other "tribes/races/etc." of people is inherent to mankind do to our evolutionary path doesn't mean that it is right, or should be supported. The desire to commit murder is a human trait, does that mean we should let people murder other people as long as it doesn't carry beyond those two individuals. How about rape? Rape is a very amoral act, and fits into our innate desire to propogate; guess we shouldn't punish people for raping either. Rape, murder, genocide, etc. are all horrible acts that while they most of the time cannot be prevented, they should definitely be punished. The state/country punishes rapists and murderers, so it is only natural to conclude that the world should punish those who commit crimes at a national level. edit: strange that I, a Muslim, a member of a religion that supposedly supports atrocities, am the one that is actually against genocide. |
|||
|
The EU is the most unrealistic and delusional political idea ever, dreamt up by career bureaucrats who want their names in history books. And now it's taken on a horrible life of its own, like a snowball in hell, that is rolling down a hill and growing at a rate slightly faster than the speed at which it is melting. |
||
|
As in, you want to find books that skim over the genocidal parts, or support them? |
|
|
Come on, tell us how you really feel. |
|||
|
At least I came up with a cool new analogy |
||||
|
It was amusing to watch him make a mockery of the court. Ah well.
|
|
Genocide? You guys sure love to abuse that word to the point of worthlessness. |
||
|
I got in trouble over at DU years ago for calling a guy a dumbass (and suggesting he look up the word) for calling the War in Iraq "genocide" of the Iraqi people. Then they banned me for no reason a few weeks later. |
|||
|
I don't know, killing a large group of people for their religious, national, ethnic, or cultural background sure counts as genocide in my book. |
|||
|
Heres the facts...we were there for political reasons. Period. End of story.
No noble bullshit about "ethnic cleansing" or saving the muslims. It was political. If we truly gave a shit about ethnic cleansing, genocide, or saving people, we would've have been in Rwanada, South Africa, hell, just about everywhere in Africa. But there is no political clout or reward for risking things there. So we let them slaughter each other. Ultimately, I really don't care if Africa or the Balkans ethnically cleanse each other out of existance. It just doesn't affect me. BUT the truth is the Serbs WERE just finally re-acting to centuries of crap from the muslims. If they were sick and tired of putting up with their bullshit, and wanted to end it for good, then they should be allowed to do what they want. That is what the muslims do...look at history. Chechnya was not an ancestral muslim home. It was Christian, or at least non muslim, until the muslims started moving in thier in the late 1800's. Once they established themselves, they started to try to force the non mulsims out. Of course the Communists in the Soviet Union kept shit in check. The muslims started stirring, and they were ruthlessly crushed. Period. After the Soviet Empire fell, the muz in Chechnya had nothing to control them. Then you have the bullshit story in the press about the poor oppressed Chechyn rebels fighting to overthrow the Russians and regain their country. IT WASN"T THEIR COUNTRY TO BEGIN WITH, they invaded and multiplied and became a majority in a land which wasn't theirs. So we here about "freedom fighters" and "rebels" when the truth is, it is simply muslims trying to ethnically cleanse an area they slowly took over. This is the way theu operate, read up on the history of islam over the centuries, it is SOP..... Sorry, the Serbs were trying to act before it was too late. Did they do it the PC way? No....but we weren't there ultimately for any higher or noble reason. It was politics. If there were no political hay to be made, the Serbs would probably be finishing the job right about now.... |
|
It is only "Genocide" if it works, by defintion. Otherwise, it is attempted genocide - or just violence targeted at a particular ethnica group, which is a more accurate description of the Bosnian mess. |
||||
|
I want to read a book that explains it, I have an understanding of what was going on over there. I want to read a book on the facts, not some left wing slant that will just try to drive home the point of what the left wing author feels about it. I tend to agree with the Serbs, I just want more information. |
||
|
Whatever dude. That's like the assertions by moonbats that Hussein was a benevolent dictator and Iraq was a place of flowers, sunshine, and fluffy bunnies before that evil Bush got involved. I'm getting the impression that there's a lot of opposition to the Bosnian thing based on who was in office at the time for more than other reasons. That said I'm pretty content with letting third-worlders kill each other off. Most cops will tell you that domestic calls suck. |
|
|
|
|
|
well, someone imght want to look at what the muz's have been doing since the end of the war. bosnia is becoming the western front of aq in europe.
having said that, slobdanob, ratboy mladic, radovan, and arkan all deserve to rot in hell. the civ muz's in bosnia didn't deserve rape camps and mass murder. they were no better than the hutu monkeys in rwanda lopping off bits of folks with their pangas... |
|
Sadly, quite a few people here tend to view women and children as valid targets for homicide; same as our enemy in the WOT, in fact. |
|
|
Wrong. The democratically elected president of Yugoslavia at the time of Milosevic's arrest was Kostunica. Milosevic had lost the election months earlier, refused to step down and was driven out by a mass uprising by Serbs. He was a monster. His goal was Serbian nationalism / fascism over everything else. The muslims were just a convienient target. |
|
|
Lemme tell you Anti-Serb Milosevic people something. You have been brainwashed by the Klinton AND MSM mainstream media BULLSHIT. Dont worry a lot of people got suckered by this, I actually belived for a few years that the serbs had set up "rape camps" That was until i learned the truth. The Truth is out there. In fact this Hague Trial was causing no small anount of embarrasment to the Euros and the "klinton policy"!! I'll Explain as best i can though this goes back 500 years!you can look up any part you doubt on the net. The plain fact is whenever a Muslim somewhere stubs his toe the whole entire muslim world rises up in support of them. Keep that in mind, they have learned well from the "isreal" situation, that in order to sway "americanski" opinion, they have to essentially go on a massive PR campaign to get political opinion on thier side. The Muslims had tons of oil on thier side (saudi etc) What do the serbs have?
Anyhew, Way back in 1992 When "nationalism" was breaking apart Yougoslavia the "old hatreds" began to surface. At this time an election of a radical Muslim happened who promised to make Bosnia a "muslims homeland" Even though there was massive intermixing of Serbs and croats as well. His followers would wear green headbands <----(see where this is going??) and hold up Korans and guess what their rally cry was?? you got it, 'Allah akbar'. Anyone who does'nt belive me look up file footage of their rallies. Also the serbs were getting pretty nationalistic too (im not gonna white wash this and say it was all the Muslims fault) SO there is still a controversy as to how the fighting started, Each side blamed the other. But suffice to say the Serbs and Muslims began fighting. The Serbs still in Serbia were giving guns , artillary , and what not to the Bosnian serbs. The Muslims raided armories and equipped thier militias but they were not doing that well. So eventually the Saudi and Iranians and what not started to flood weapons into the region, ALONG WITH MUJAHADEEN FIGHTERS. It was at this "escalation point" where Nato and the us put an embargo into effect on all sides. they did'nt want it to get worse. Now onto the whole "atrocities bullshit", Both sides did equal ethnic cleansing. But the Saudis hired a Jewish PR firm (how ironic!) to begin lobbing the capitol to take the side of the Muslims and warned Clinton that NOT taking the side of the Muslims WOULD PISS THE SAUDIS OFF. SO? klinton chose to side with the Mujahedeen. What does this have to do With Kosovo? Well essentially the same thing happened there, The media already behind the idea of the "wicked serb" Just claimed all over again that there was ethnic cleansing and CLinton started the bombing. In fact the only Ethnic cleansing was done to the SERBS BY US! Now all the Serbs fear for their lives And most have moved out. linky more stuff this is just a small sampling, i suggest you look up the whole history of the KLA and "greater Albania" Milosvic was a fucking hero as is Arkan , Radcovic and all the other "defenders" of Europe from the ROPers. ETA: notice how the local ARFCOM Roper ,Premedgunner ,takes the side of the Albanians on this post, that right there should tell you volumes. |
|
Good post. |
|
|
|
||
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.