Quoted:
Quoted: I'm expecting several thousand dollars from USAA any day now!! Cancelled the last policy with them a little over 6months ago and the balance of my SSA is paying out in full. Woo Hoo!!
Of course i wish that they had just lived up to the reputation and treated me fairly in the first place. Seems that the USAA since about 1995 is not that same USAA that I started with in 1988 and that my dad started with in 1969. Until 6 months ago i had never had coverage from any company other than USAA. I did work for a number of other carriers and had offers for coverage, but no reason to change. Then USAA gave me the reason to change.
|
What problem did you have with them?
|
Only had two claims since 1988. THe first one was on a renter's policy in 1993 (they paid less than 1500 for a theft claim) and they handled it like a champ. Then in early 2001 (end of January) we had an ice storm in KC. It spanned over three days as we were without electiricity etc. Despite it being one catastrophy under the insurance contract and the KS DOI regs they reported it to the CLUE service (this is roughly the equivalent of a credit report for insurance claims) as three claims. Seems that the damage to one room they reported on one day, the tree that fell on another day and finally the food spoilage (that I did not even turn in for reimburtsement but they assumed woudl be filed and opened a reserve) on day three. THen I get a non-renewal letter that says "due to your claims frequence (three claims in one year)" you are being non-renewed on you April 1 anniversary date. I asked them to change the CLUE report to actually reflect the single loss (the total for all "three losses" was less than $1000 before duductible). THey refused and I filed a complaint withthe DOI. The DOI sided with me on the issues, but had no power to force a company to report a loss to CLUE in any particular way as CLUE is a private reporting service. The only avenue I woudl have had was a bad faith claim or an injunction neither of which really seemed to fit the situation.
The situation only got worse because they sent the non-renewal to the wrong address.
They are required to send notice of non-renewal to the last address of the insured with no less than 30 days until the policy anniversary. Despite the fact I lived at the same address that they insured they transposed a few numbers on the address. It got to me in time, but I waited until about 29 days before the policy anniversary to let them know of the mistake. As such they had to withdraw the non-renewal as there was no time left to correct the error and issue the no-renewal with the 30 day notice.
I contacted an agent friend of mine and we got a quote on replacement coverage through a natioanl carrier. He had no problem with the clue report and advised that he had seen several things like this from them in the last several years. USAA has been reducing its exposure in teh midwest due to our floods, hail and ice and the best way to do that is to non-renew people with claims. I was obvious to him that the "three" losses on consecutive days were actually part of one catastrophic loss. I waited until two months before the next anniversary assuming that they would have me diaried for non-renewal and swithced carriers at that time. After teh cancellation I received a notice of non-renewal. It was ineffective as the policy had already been terminated by me. I can't say I enjoyed the stress, but whipping them at their own game was a certain sort of satisfaction.
I was apprehensive about leaving USAA as they had been very good to me in the years without claims. I had home, auto, Umbrella, Credit cards, car loan and a savings account with them for 13 years. However, I got on with another company and have actually gotten a better rate for slightly better coverage (no serial numbers needed for Firearms coverage endorsements). Given my experience my dad (a USAA member since 1969) and my brother ( a member since 1994) all called and complained and ended up dropping USAA in favor of other compaines.
Of course, being in the insurance industry I understand the backstory for they company trying to limit losses and exposure, but that does nto make it any easier when I am the once being axed. For years I expected, and got, better of USAA. I now see them as really no different than any other large P&C carrier. If they had the better price, I'd take it. But they just don't have the "something extra" anymore that made themt he hands down choice if all else was equal.
YMMV,