"The Second Amendment gives people the right to own guns, but they shouldn't be allowed to own high capacity assault weapons, because they don't serve a sporting purpose. And all guns should be registered, for safety's sake."
View Quote
Does the first Amendment give us a right to speak? No. It protects our right to speak. We have this right, with or without the Constitution. All the 1st Amendment does is enumerate the right, so as to protect it from any and all government attempts to regulate it. Correct?
The 2nd Amendment does not "give" us a right to keep and bear arms, it protects that right, just as the 1st protects our right to free speech. The often abused militia clause was inserted to state the reason to protect that right. The right is protected so that we may be able to call up an adequately armed militia, comprised of citizens well practiced in the use of arms. In order that we may have an effective militia, the people must keep and bear arms of a military value. To do otherwise would be useless.
You may argue that there is no need for a well armed miltia since you believe that our government is above doing anything which would endager our liberties. You may be right, or you may be wrong, but recent events lead me to believe that you are wrong. Waco and Ruby Ridge are prime examples.
While you may argue that these are isolated incidents, I beleive they were a test of the resolve of the people. So far, I believe we passed the test, and the radical left is back to whittling away our RKBA.
Now for some numbers: It is claimed that some 30,000 people lose their lives each year to firarms here in the US. Among these 30,000, there is said to be about 4,000 young people, up to age 20.
In the 20th century, 56 million people lost their lives to their governments after they were disarmed. That amounts to 560,000 each year, every year, for 100 years. If a mere 10% were young people, up to age 20, that would be 56,000 killed each year, or almost double the total of all firearms fatalities in the US each year, and almost the exact number of American servicemen killed in Vietnam throughout the war.
I prefer to take my chances with an armed civilian population.