Quoted:
[traditionalist rant]
Go traditional. Get you a caplock Hawkins or Pennsylvania or Kentucky rifle.
[/traditionalist rant]
View Quote
i shoot a model 1861 springfield (enfields are good too) clone in .58 caliber. VERY satisfying. also very dirty. gentle blackpowder shove, resounding [b]BOOM![/b], immense cloud of smoke. downrange, the "big ol' chunk o' lead" goes "THWAP!" when it hits the berm. wonderful!
the springfield is a big rifle, and runs about $450. the sights are poor, you can't get .58 cal minie' bullets at wal-mart and you've absolutely got to keep it clean. but it's a beautiful piece, and it's got some history.
lady lurker uses a .50 cal hawken. i taught her to use minie' bullets instead of patched balls, and she says it's much more pleasant to shoot.
a further note i learned the hard way. if you reenact, you MUST use black powder. pyrodex does not burn well unless rammed.