User Panel
Originally Posted By Kitties-with-Sigs: Why don't you like pocket hole jigs? I'm new and trying to learn, so please give the "For dummies" version. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Kitties-with-Sigs: Originally Posted By SpankMonkey: What's, in your opinion, the most overrated tool that sucks woodworkers in like fishermen to lures? Pocket hole jigs. Why don't you like pocket hole jigs? I'm new and trying to learn, so please give the "For dummies" version. Basically they are for dummies :) Or at least they are certainly not used in fine woodworking. |
|
“Everyone takes a beating sometimes”
— ADA in KR case, November 15, 2021. |
Kreg:
Love or hate their pocket screw setups for joinery? ETA: Heh. should have cruised the thread before I asked! |
|
|
I use pocket holes for joinery that is not seen.
When I get a new table saw I will finally be able to start m and t joinery. |
|
Do not allow anyone to track you or spy on you. Pay for a good VPN, use firefox, ghostery, privacy badger, httpseverwhere, and clearnURLs. Ditch social media. TURN OFF AMAZON SIDEWALK!! Lock down your home network! PROTECT YOUR DATA!
|
Born with a low tolerance for bullshit
KY, USA
|
Originally Posted By madwis15: Basically they are for dummies :) Or at least they are certainly not used in fine woodworking. View Quote ETA: Wait. Are you the OP or are you just being a poopyhead? I know a lot of NOT dummies, who use pockethole joinery and I'd like to know why OP doesn't like it. Ya, Ima keep asking til the OP talks. For things like kitchen cabinet case joinery that will never be seen, they seemed to me to be a strong, quicker option (keep in mind that I'm new and don't have a lot of joinery experience, and fine joinery may never be a big part of it, but I'm watching and learning and trying things.) For "fine woodworking" I assume you mean some of the lovely furniture and other pieces that folks have posted on this forum, among other things. I think most cabinetmakers (at least the ones who put stuff in the houses I rehab) don't spend the time on dovetails that won't ever be seen, and though the good ones don't just shoot things together with staples (I've had some of that in one house...it was bad. Had to get it redone) they also, for time and efficiency, do things that are strong and fast in their pre-assembly shop/process for the boxes themselves. For kitchen cabinets in the average home, what's wrong with pockethole joinery? |
Nobody ever wakes me at 2 in the morning telling me that my grass is out on the highway.~~Radiopat
Wine is sunlight held together by water~~Galileo Galilei Well-behaved women rarely make history~~Marilyn Monroe |
|
Originally Posted By SpankMonkey: Pocket hole jigs are good for simple projects or production environments. Building fine furniture it would not be acceptable. View Quote Why? Very simple question. Too fast? Too easy? There's no structural reason why pocket hole joinery would be insufficient on concealed joints. "Fine furniture" is a nonsense term, and I'm a woodworker who doesn't use pocket hole joinery often. |
|
|
Originally Posted By FS7: Why? Very simple question. Too fast? Too easy? There's no structural reason why pocket hole joinery would be insufficient on concealed joints. "Fine furniture" is a nonsense term, and I'm a woodworker who doesn't use pocket hole joinery often. View Quote We have different opinions on fine furniture. I wont use pocket holes on my furniture. You do you, I'll do me. |
|
|
Born with a low tolerance for bullshit
KY, USA
|
Originally Posted By SpankMonkey: We have different opinions on fine furniture. I wont use pocket holes on my furniture. You do you, I'll do me. View Quote So...by "cabinetmaker" based on the title of your thread...do you mean everyday kitchen cabinets? Or fine furniture cabinets? That's probably going to get read differently by different people, depending on their starting point. I read it as "kitchen cabinetmaker" which I thought meant high-end cabinets for the home. If you are talking about cabinets ala Roentgens or something that is not going to take a lot of hard, everyday use, I certainly understand that pockethole joinery would never be acceptable in that kind of work. I would love to know more about what you do and how you define fine furniture vs common, everyday workhorses. |
Nobody ever wakes me at 2 in the morning telling me that my grass is out on the highway.~~Radiopat
Wine is sunlight held together by water~~Galileo Galilei Well-behaved women rarely make history~~Marilyn Monroe |
Originally Posted By SpankMonkey: We have different opinions on fine furniture. I wont use pocket holes on my furniture. You do you, I'll do me. View Quote If your only reason is your own sensibilities, that's fine, but it's also unfair to suggest that "fine furniture" does not use pocket holes. https://www.amazon.com/Furniture-Masterworks-John-Thomas-Seymour/dp/0883891263 You will find plenty of pocket holes appearing in that book - a book about the works of two of the finest Federal period craftsmen to have lived. In fact, many antique furniture uses pocket holes rather extensively. It's not like the technology was invented by Kreg. They made it convenient and let a lot of new people get into woodworking. They are quick, clean, and strong, and certainly appropriate for concealed joints. The strength of the joint has been debated, but that's true with anybody's preferred method (dowels, M&T, loose tenons) as they argue over which one you can land a helicopter on. Pocket holes are not for exposed joints, and the plugs don't really help with that. The absolutely perfect joints shown in Kreg literature look OK, but I have only ever plugged a hole if a joint could be felt (like the back of a face frame) but not seen. I have yet to see or hear any good reason why pocket holes are not suitable for concealed joints other than personal preference. |
|
|
I can see OP's point on pocket holes. Makes sense to me. Woodworking for some is an art, not just a job that needs to get done. And that art is usually based on the way woodworking was done hundreds of years ago. You know what the difference between a carpenter and a ship builder was many years ago? Not much. One was making bigger pieces of wood lock together using joinery methods and the other was making smaller pieces of wood lock together.
When I visited Key West one of the points brought up was how has the houses down there lasted as long as they have with all the hurricanes that have hit that area. Some of the homes are hundreds of years old. Answer was they were build by ship builders that used locking joinery with wood pins like they did on ships. I see pocket holes kind of like this: Film vs. digital photography hand shaped body panels vs. half gallon of body filler over so-so fitting panels painting on canvas/paper vs. paint by number This is why so many wood workers seek out old world tools and restore them and put them back to work again. This is why they pass down the techniques used before the table saw and router was invented. FWIW, I use the shit out of some pocket holes! |
|
|
Originally Posted By Kitties-with-Sigs: For things like kitchen cabinet case joinery that will never be seen, they seemed to me to be a strong, quicker option (keep in mind that I'm new and don't have a lot of joinery experience, and fine joinery may never be a big part of it, but I'm watching and learning and trying things.) View Quote I built my current round of cabinet carcasses with pocket holes. The most annoying problem was that the screws pull with a shear and then that can pull the alignment off, especially at the corners. I build some jigs and used clamps to minimize this, but it's still a pain in the ass and visible on frameless cabinets. Now that I have a Domino, I may use those to hold alignment and pocket screws to clamp the glue joint. I'm going to make some test pieces and see how it goes. The next kitchen will also be frameless and I want perfect corners, not slipped by a 32nd or 16th. |
|
Pigeons are Liars
If it flies, it spies. |
Originally Posted By Andr0id: I built my current round of cabinet carcasses with pocket holes. The most annoying problem was that the screws pull with a shear and then that can pull the alignment off, especially at the corners. I build some jigs and used clamps to minimize this, but it's still a pain in the ass and visible on frameless cabinets. Now that I have a Domino, I may use those to hold alignment and pocket screws to clamp the glue joint. I'm going to make some test pieces and see how it goes. The next kitchen will also be frameless and I want perfect corners, not slipped by a 32nd or 16th. View Quote Somewhere I saw a tip on how to prevent this "pocket screw pull". They used a brad gun and shot a brad into the surface, but somehow held it up so it didn't penetrate all the way. I think they used cardboard? They then snipped the head off with dykes and used the brad sticking up to grip the wood like a spike so it didn't slide as the pocket screw was tightened down. I'll see if I can find that again. |
|
|
Originally Posted By FS7: Why? Very simple question. Too fast? Too easy? There's no structural reason why pocket hole joinery would be insufficient on concealed joints. "Fine furniture" is a nonsense term, and I'm a woodworker who doesn't use pocket hole joinery often. View Quote |
|
"Over the years, it has become increasingly difficult to tell the difference between skilled trolls versus fucking morons." DK-Prof
|
Originally Posted By winddummy82: fine furniture uses traditional joinery, mortise and tenon, dovetail / blind dovetail, dado and rabbit etc. pocket hole is anything but fine. have a obese person sit on a table or chair made with traditional joinery and wiggle around it's no big deal. then have the same obese person sit on a table or chair made with pocket screws and see what happens. View Quote And there it is. ARF picking on us fat people again…… But excellent point. |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By AR15Texan: How can I fix this gouge and scratches to the finish of my wood console shifter bezel? https://i.ibb.co/4R2rqZm/IMG-20220205-163954559.jpg View Quote Polish with 2000 grit auto polish and then 3000 grit polish. Touch up gouge with a dark walnut touch up pen. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07TY6QJTN?tag=arfcom00-20 |
|
|
Originally Posted By Kitties-with-Sigs: ETA: Wait. Are you the OP or are you just being a poopyhead? I know a lot of NOT dummies, who use pockethole joinery and I'd like to know why OP doesn't like it. Ya, Ima keep asking til the OP talks. For things like kitchen cabinet case joinery that will never be seen, they seemed to me to be a strong, quicker option (keep in mind that I'm new and don't have a lot of joinery experience, and fine joinery may never be a big part of it, but I'm watching and learning and trying things.) For "fine woodworking" I assume you mean some of the lovely furniture and other pieces that folks have posted on this forum, among other things. I think most cabinetmakers (at least the ones who put stuff in the houses I rehab) don't spend the time on dovetails that won't ever be seen, and though the good ones don't just shoot things together with staples (I've had some of that in one house...it was bad. Had to get it redone) they also, for time and efficiency, do things that are strong and fast in their pre-assembly shop/process for the boxes themselves. For kitchen cabinets in the average home, what's wrong with pockethole joinery? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Kitties-with-Sigs: Originally Posted By madwis15: Basically they are for dummies :) Or at least they are certainly not used in fine woodworking. ETA: Wait. Are you the OP or are you just being a poopyhead? I know a lot of NOT dummies, who use pockethole joinery and I'd like to know why OP doesn't like it. Ya, Ima keep asking til the OP talks. For things like kitchen cabinet case joinery that will never be seen, they seemed to me to be a strong, quicker option (keep in mind that I'm new and don't have a lot of joinery experience, and fine joinery may never be a big part of it, but I'm watching and learning and trying things.) For "fine woodworking" I assume you mean some of the lovely furniture and other pieces that folks have posted on this forum, among other things. I think most cabinetmakers (at least the ones who put stuff in the houses I rehab) don't spend the time on dovetails that won't ever be seen, and though the good ones don't just shoot things together with staples (I've had some of that in one house...it was bad. Had to get it redone) they also, for time and efficiency, do things that are strong and fast in their pre-assembly shop/process for the boxes themselves. For kitchen cabinets in the average home, what's wrong with pockethole joinery? I’m neither the OP, nor a poopyhead! I believe I have been vindicated in this thread! |
|
“Everyone takes a beating sometimes”
— ADA in KR case, November 15, 2021. |
OP, favorite brand of parallel clamps do you use? And which brands do you avoid?
|
|
Work, work, work....curse of the drinking man
|
Originally Posted By deLuna_tic: OP, favorite brand of parallel clamps do you use? And which brands do you avoid? View Quote I use a brand no longer made. Modern favorite would be Jorgensen great quality and price second would be Jett or Bessy. I now avoid Irwin. The quality has really gone down hill. |
|
|
Originally Posted By SpankMonkey: I use a brand no longer made. Modern favorite would be Jorgensen great quality and price second would be Jett or Bessy. I now avoid Irwin. The quality has really gone down hill. View Quote Irwin's trigger clamps are very useful for face lamination and other smaller jobs where you can easily use two dozen of them. They are very handy. I have never used their parallel clamps, but they are well-regarded. I imagine they're identical to other brands. For what it's worth I have not had much of a problem with cheap Powertec parallel clamps. I think the primary reason I reach for them is they are less than half the weight of the Jorgensen clamps. I mean the Jorgensens are a workhorse and that's reflected in the weight. The only bad clamps of any type I've used are the smaller Bessey bar clamps. I assume they're light duty because the bar bends very easily. They still work, but it's surprising to see the bar turn into a bow. |
|
|
Men are only men, Little Brother, and their talk is like the talk of frogs in a pond.
|
Proud member of the LGBFJB community
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.