Quote History Quoted:
That’s a good point. I’d hope to find some games I and possibly my wife could play, but as a fallback position $500 for a 4K minecraft might not be the best choice.
It will probably come down to whether I can think of a better toy for Christmas (for me). I like to get at least one fun present each year. If I can’t think of a better one, the X will probably be it.
View Quote
In the case of the X I find it a really tough sell personally. I have a ps4, xbone, and a pretty nice PC. I play the PC mostly but I see the attraction of the consoles so I generally consider myself unbiased. If somebody is looking into a PC I think that is usually the best bet. If a console person wants a new console a new console is going to be the right answer, I'm not one to pull the PC master race crap when it's unsolicited. That said I think if you have that kind of cash to spend on a console I'd personally go PS4 Pro. The UI is better on Sony's end for the time being and while I personally don't care for VR at this stage the PSVR is actually a pretty decent set for the cash. The PS4 Pro would be the best experience for VR unless microsoft has something coming soon. Microsoft has been dumping some time and money into VR so I would expect them to release a nice set when they're ready but for the upcoming holiday season I think PSVR and a PS4 Pro would be the best bang for your buck.
I don't follow the console wars like I used to admittedly, but personally higher frame rates and HDR have been more of a "holy shit" visual experience than just 4k by itself. The PS4 Pro is the more attractive entrance point in that regard.
However, in your case since you already have an xbox one I do think it would still be worth looking into the X if there are games you want to play with the family because you can have people playing on both Xboxes in that case, or since you're talking minecraft you could have two family members on the Xboxes and somebody playing on a PC as well (assuming you have a laptop/desktop that runs minecraft which I assume most people likely do).