Kata is a controversial topic of the martial arts, it ranks right up the with the: GM vs. Ford, 9mm vs. 45, colt vs. Bushmaster, blonds vs. brunets, Big cans vs. Small cans, etc. etc.
There are many different thoughts / options on this subject. I certainly don’t wish to start a pissing contest. One option on Kata’s is that it is tradition, Some teach kata with the only goal or out come of Kata is that it is required to get your next belt. Some teach an hour class of karate broken down into, one part kata, one part exercises, one part sparring, one part self defense, or something like this. These classes more or less are teaching 4 different topics.
One other thought on Kata is that there has to be more to it. Why in the heck would Masters have done Kata all their life? How could Masters be so deadly? Perhaps there is more to Kata.
In the School I have been studying, Kata is taught as a tool to teach self-defense. Kata is like show and tell. Your hand moving toward you could possibly be an opponent’s hand moving toward you (the show), the next part of the move maybe the response to the attack. (the tell). Kata is the language that maps out where you attack your opponent at.
On common thing heard about Kata is that it’s totally BS (Funky Dances). Why would I fight 3 opponents with this form? Why would 2 of 3 opponents watch me take one out, then wait there turn for me to attack them? This is very true. 3 attackers would just come at you at once in this day of age. We interpret a move that may repeat itself in different directions, differently than above. A turn in a Kata could tell you that you either are turning your opponent to you, or your turning yourself to your opponent. Isn’t it common that you may step off 45 degrees to an opponent when parring a punch? A lot of forms have moves in them moving to a 45… Repeating a move 3 times in different direction just may mean that it would work in all 3 directions not that its 3 attackers.
All my self-defense that I know comes right out of the Kata. This to me makes my Kata more meaningful to me. When I practice my form I can be visualizing an attack so that when the attack occurs I have that muscular memory already developed from my forms.
I repeat, this is just my opinion, and I wish to start no flames here. I certainly wish you stick with it and I wish you the best of luck. I started the arts late in life and it has made a very positive impact on my life. I hope it does to you also........