I started shooting a compound back when 45% to 50% let off was the norm and just before eccentric cams started showing up when arrow speeds were about the same as recurves - in the 175-185 fps range.
Now with let offs in the 75% to 90% range, and arrow speeds in the 250-300 fps range, I put them in the same category as in-line muzzle loaders.
I much prefer to hunt with a traditional muzzle loader (.54 Hawken or a .58 rifled musket) because the modern in-line black powder rifles lack the feel, the history, and quite frankly the intent of hunting with a primitive rifle. They suck all the fun out of it, and make it a lot less rewarding.
In the same way, modern compound bow takes much of the challenge and fun out of bow hunting.
I do make a nod to technology in the form of a plain pin sight - but no peep, no stabilizer, no fancy rest, etc. It's about the right balance between traditional and practical, and makes the skill of the archer in both tuning the bow and making the shot much more important.