Quoted:
Question: My buddy is "law enforcement", would he be allowed to carry his back up piece in the woods while bow hunting on private property ?
No.
http://www.dec.ny.gov/regulations/2442.html
Handgun
Question: Can I carry my handgun while hunting?
Answer:
Yes, providing the barrel length is less than 16 inches and you are a
New York State resident with a valid New York State pistol permit.
However; you cannot carry one if you are archery or muzzleloader
hunting during those special seasons.
Question: What is the minimum and maximum handgun barrel
length that is allowed when using a handgun to hunt big game in areas
where the use of a pistol is legal?
Answer: Maximum legal
barrel length is 16 inches. There is no minimum barrel length.
Autoloading pistols must have a barrel length of less than 8 inches.
Any center-fire caliber is legal when hunting big game with a handgun.
Question: I hold a New York State Pistol Permit, can I carry my pistol while bow hunting or muzzleloader hunting?
Answer:
No, even though you possess a valid pistol permit to carry the pistol,
the Environmental Conservation Law (ECL) states the following: No
person engaged in hunting deer or bear pursuant to a bowhunting stamp
or muzzleloader stamp and no person accompanying him or a member of his
party, while he is so engaged in hunting during a special longbow or
muzzleloader season, shall have in his possession a firearm of any
kind. A pistol is defined as a firearm in the Environmental
Conservation Law and possession is not allowed afield with or near a
person while they are engaged in hunting pursuant to the special bow or
muzzleloader season.
Question: Can I carry my licensed pistol while bow or muzzleloader hunting if I am a Peace or Police officer?
Answer:
Environmental Conservation Law states that "No person" can carry a
firearm of "any kind" while hunting under the authority of a bow-stamp
or muzzleloader stamp. There is no provision under this section of law
which exempts police or peace officers. The answer is NO.
Question: Can I carry a handgun while archery hunting during the regular big game season?
Answer: Yes. You may not however, carry a firearm while archery hunting during a special archery season.