From my post count you can tell I don’t often say much but I’ve been around for a while and have to comment on this one.
I'd like for anyone to give me one solid factual reason why an XD is better than a Glock.
I think both are good weapons and
IF money wasn't an object, I'd buy an XD (probably in .45) to go along with my Glock 22 (.40 cal) and 1911.
Glocks have been around for a long time and have proven themselves time and time again as reliable functioning weapons with minimal problems. There are several extream tourcher test that demonstrate the abuse these things can take. This is not to say that an XD won’t do the same, they’ve just not been around as long and I've yet to see a test.
I've had thousands of rounds through mine with nothing more than running a bore snake through it once in a while.
The kaboom crowd will always chim in here
, however in most all cases it can be attributed to hot hand loaded rounds. I’ve seen documented cases of just about every other mfg's gun with catastophic failures so it's not limited to Glocks.
Also, DON'T USE LEAD BULLETS! With the octagonal rifled barrels on Glocks, the barrel will lead up fast and lead to extremely high pressures with NORMAL loads (possible kaboom).
If you shoot factory ammo, you will (99.99% of the time) never have any problems. In the other .01%, it simply a matter of numbers. With all the Glocks out there, (as with any other manufacturer), there will be failures and sometime they will be catastrophic.
Some will point to the grip safety. This is another preference and comfort factor. It gives some people that extra level of comfort. If it does you, then go with the XD. Ultimatly your brain and finger are your SAFETY!!!!
If your finger is not on the trigger, neither gun will go off.
Decide on what you intended use is, caliber you want, what size frame you want, and then grip both guns and see which one fits better (ergonomics) and buy that one. If you have a chance, I'd shoot both before buying either.
As I said, both are good guns…It boils down to preference!
Good luck with your choice
Oh, and I thnk Glocks are more aesthetically pleasing