Reporting back.
For a 12mbps / 896 kbps line, it works as advertised (did my speedtest.net tests).
Setup was uh ... ummmmm 3 days worth of rant from me, but that was due to the my specific requirements (which I consider simple actually), I just need to be able to browse, get mail, serve a web page, and use apple's wireless airtunes (this one requires apple's Airport Extreme basestation, and where the trouble of the tribbles come in).
Long story short, mainstream typical setup (i.e. you replace your basestation with Qwest's modem router/wireless) is really brain dead simple, take it out of the box, follow the instructions, you're done. This gets you a mini LAN (PK5000 modem has 4 ports in the back), and wireless turned on and secured.
To solve my setup, I had to set the modem into Transparent Bridging (somewhere in the Advanced Setup -> IP Addressing sub menu). WARNING: you will never be able to see your modem addressable with an IP address anymore once you do this (unless you do a hard reset which is magic that I don't know).
Then plug in the Apple Extreme base station into the back of the PK5000 modem. My base station is set to share a public address, and to dial-up with PPPoE (PPP over Ethernet), so you absolutely must know the userid and password to connect (or call the repair/tech support service if you don't know it).
Again, as you can't see the modem and doesn't initiate the connection, you must use/create a PPPoE connection from your base station (or your PC/Mac if your PC is connected directly to the modem).
Note that I have tried the simple standard QWest modem setup, and set the PK5000 modem to port forwarding, and my Apple basestation to also bridging (i.e. only function as a wireless router). Neither solved the various problems I had (practically killed Youtube, mail, and other functions due to speed issues). I believe the issue is in the interaction between PK5000 modem and Apple's base station
For reference QWest DSL technical support # is 1-888-777-9569 (they must like the wide body Boeing 777
)
Yes, and I am sure that I'm the first one to encounter this problem and offer this solution. I googled really hard and did not found any solution that was close (apart from finding out that you can set the dang modem to transparent bridging).
Oh and another thing that slows QWest down is that after a long session of idle DNS request activity from your connection they drop you off the load balancing DNS server bank. When you start browsing, the pages you hit (or any application) you hit will be slow as molasses until you get assigned to a DNS server bank. After that the browsing and application response times are really fast.
In the browser, you see this phenomena as "Looking for <yoursite here>" in the status bar that goes for about 5-10 seconds. I browse and my email is on early in the morning, late night, and sometimes odd hours. So I'm hit with molasses frequently (but sounds like others are experiencing this as well).
That just means I have to setup a script that does random name resolution requests every 5 minutes or so.
Also another issue, sending mail takes a noticeably longer amount of time, given the 896 kbps upload speed.
This might be the twig that broke the camel's back for me.
ETA: more technical details added.
Summary:
- Upload speed, DNS lookup times broke this deal for me
- In absence of the above the solution with Apple Airport Extreme is to
- Set the Apple Airport Extreme to Share a Public Address, and dial up using PPPoE (need qwest DSL userid & password)
- Set the PK5000 modem to Transparent Bridging mode (WARNING as above, you'll need technical support to bring the modem back to normal mode)