Measure restricts gun permit data
Names could be kept from media
Thursday, March 16, 2006
Reginald Fields
Plain Dealer Bureau
Columbus- Gun permit holders would be allowed to shield their names from journalists following a late change to a proposed open records bill.
The move on Wednesday stunned Rep. Scott Oelslager, the bill's sponsor, who thought he had defeated attempts to insert the restrictions into the bill in recent weeks.
"I did not know this was coming until right before I walked in here," Oelslager, a Canton Republican, said on the floor of the Ohio House, moments after his bill was approved with the opt-out provision for permit holders.
Earlier in the day, House Bill 9 was voted out of committee - 14 months after it was introduced - and Oelslager said he was satisfied the legislation was finally moving forward.
That was before one of his colleagues got hold of it on the House floor.
Rep. Tom Brinkman Jr., a Cincinnati Republican, introduced an amendment that maintains journalists' access to the concealed-carry lists, but allows permit holders to request that their names not be released.
He said the amendment was for the safety of permit holders who might have legitimate reasons for not wanting their names publicly disseminated. The amendment, however, says nothing about supplying a reason for opting off the lists.
Brinkman and other GOP lawmakers then chided the news media, including The Plain Dealer, for publishing the names of permit holders. The public otherwise does not have access to the information.
Oelslager tried to kill Brinkman's amendment but was defeated. In a bipartisan vote, the House accepted the amendment, 51-43. The bill was then approved by the full House, 93-1. Oelslager voted yes.
"If journalists would simply stop abusing the lists by publishing all the names, we wouldn't be talking about this now," Rep. Jim Aslanides, a Coshocton Republican, said after the vote.
"That is not what the law was intended for. It was intended to make sure the law was working," Aslanides said. The media "didn't comply with the law."
Plain Dealer Editor Doug Clifton disagrees.
"We have always believed that the public should have access to these records, not just the press," Clifton said. "That's why we published the permit holders' names.
"This amendment is just another slap in the public's face," he said.
To opt out, permit holders would have to sign an affidavit requesting it or check a box on the application when applying for or renewing a firearms license. Oelslager noted the bill is headed to the Senate, where it still could be changed.
Late Wednesday, Gov. Bob Taft again said he would veto any bill that restricts media access to the permit lists. He urged the Senate to take the provision out of HB 9.
Senate President Bill Harris, an Ashland Republican, said he had not yet reviewed the bill or the amendment.
The amendment overshadowed the bulk of the public records bill, which contains several new components to make public records more accessible.
The audit and paperwork of private firms hired by the state auditor for outsourced jobs would be public documents under another change made on Wednesday.
Also, public entities that do not readily supply records can be fined, and public officials or their designees have to undergo public records training
WOOHOO!.....I'll be clicking that box when I fill out my application.....
....Let's hope it gets through the Senate.......
....I swear, I'm starting to like these Republicans