If you are hard up and don't mind a drive, Cleland's in Swanton, Ohio had .38, .357 and 9mm American Eagle, and plenty of it. They had .40 S&W also, though I can't remember what brand. There were other brands, but they had alot of the AE. It is at 10306 Airport Highway (419-865-4713) (exit 8 off 475 south, then head west). They are also having a tent sale and had odds and ends, knives, scopes, mags, gun cases at pretty good prices. I picked up 158grain hard cast .38/.357 bullets for around $36/500, which made my trip.
No, I don't work for them, I just spent the morning with my uncle and we stopped by there and were surprised by the amount of handgun ammo on the shelf.