Do some research on these rounds. I "read" that the 135 grain gold dot bullet was not designed to be driven at 357 velocities, which caused it to break up on several independent pen tests. Speer is supposedly aware of the issue, and their official statement is that the rounds "should be fine" in real world applications. I know for a fact that NYPD has put the short barrel 38+P gold dots into numerous bad guys with succesful results, so I am sticking with 38+P. I did shoot the short barrel 357's just to see how they are, and they were not nearly as hard to handle as I thought (same gun, MP 340CT, and yes the CT grip takes a bit of recoil out)