Has anyone purchased from them in the past?  I'm thinking about buying my Gold Cup from them and man are they cheap almost to cheap. The Colt Gold Cup Trophy is only $946 plus shipping.

Yeah they are in my hometown and have used them for both purchases and transfers. I wouldnt hesitate to do business with them. I would just email them to make sure what they have is actually in stock and confirm the price. Mr. Kotula is in the USAF and may be on deployment, if he is, his wife (i think) handles the business so just shoot them an email to double check. They will do you right you wont have to worry about getting scammed.