Toyota Kool aid.
We bought a 2005 Matrix New. It has about 60K miles on it. It has been dead nuts reliable, but is a fucking rattle bucket. So much so that we're having the dealer tear the front dash out on the next service to find the damned rattles and squeeks. Google "Matrix rattles"
Drive it over some bumpy roads to see if you have similar issues.
What amazes me is how people think a car they probably paid barely $18K for in 2004, and has over 200K miles on it, should still sell for $10K or some absurd straight line depreciation out to 500K miles.
For my own personal experience, I might possibly be persuaded to buy a new Toyota, but would certainly never buy a used one as they just don't seem to be worth it at used prices.
ETA: The asking price of $1500 is probably reasonable. If you get 6-months of motoring out of it and then junk it for parts, it probably doesn't owe you much. But driving something that you can be fairly certain will let you down, is not something I'd be keen on.