Member Login
Posted: 1/6/2012 8:10:22 AM EDT
[Last Edit: 1/6/2012 8:13:38 AM EDT by diehippy]
I have a horizontal cylindrical tank that I need to calculate volume changes in....based on % of liquid height in the tank. It has round ends, but for simplicity we'll assume this is a plain horizontal cylinder. As far as I can think, this is probably a fairly simple integral calculation for change in area * tank length, but I've forgot most of this stuff. Anybody have a reference formula handy for this?
EDIT: radius = 60", length = 410" 


Calculate the area of the circle on the end multiplied by the length of the tank.
A= pi x r2 x length of tank. 


Originally Posted By 7n6: Calculate the area of the circle on the end multiplied by the length of the tank. A= pi x r2 x length of tank. It would be easy to include the ends too since it's just a sphere. Make sure you don't double it though. A lot of kids will do that. Unless I'm misunderstanding your problem you should just be able to take the % of the volume for the reult you want.
ETA: I see your dilemma now. I can't do the ends on the tank. Sorry. You may try wolframalpha.com though.
ETA II: I also read too fast and now see that the tank is horizontal. What a bunch of BS!



Originally Posted By 7n6: Calculate the area of the circle on the end multiplied by the length of the tank. A= pi x r2 x length of tank. Yes, but I need to know the volume from different liquid heights. A change from 510% full is small compared to 4550% full in volume. 


Originally Posted By 7n6:
Calculate the area of the circle on the end multiplied by the length of the tank. A= pi x r2 x length of tank. That will give him volume but the volume changes based on liquid height will be nonlinear as it fills since there will be more volume in the center section than there is at the top or the bottom. 

You may all go to hell, and I will go to Texas
WildHogHunters.com 
i have a calculator for doing just that ... i will need the tank height ( or liquid level for that volume ) the dia of the tank or vessel, and the distance from the tangent line for the depth of the dish bottom head.
i inspect tanks for a living 

The brand makes no difference when the owner is an idiot.  Dragracer_Art:

Originally Posted By sinsir: i have a calculator for doing just that ... i will need the tank height ( or liquid level for that volume ) the dia of the tank or vessel, and the distance from the tangent line for the depth of the dish bottom head. i inspect tanks for a living pm sent 


Fuck, I've got a headache now.


NRA Benefactor Life, NRA Golden Eagle, NRA Recruiter, Second Amendment Foundation
Life Member. LIVE FREE OR DIE. MOLON LABE!!! FBHO!!!! 
Easier to do a subtraction.
You're taking the full volume of the tank and subtracting the secant volume that's unfilled. Start here. Now, Wikipedia suggests using the area of a sector, minus the isoscles triangle at its base. A good approach, but it forces you to calculate the angle theta, which is annoying. If you're using a spreadsheet or other simple calculator, then no problem. Just run a couple extra formulas and be done with it. But if you're trying to come up with a single formula suitable for field use (like a placard on the tank), it gets much trickier. There's no simple fieldusable formula, and you're better off graduating the existing level indicator with volume ticks at precalculated intervals. 




The brand makes no difference when the owner is an idiot.  Dragracer_Art:

Volume at depth h = Length * Area of segment
Area = rad^2*ACOS((radh)/rad)(radh)*(2*rad*hh^2)^0.5 




ONLY PEOPLE WHO LACK A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF CONFIDENCE AND CAN'T COME UP WITH A DECENT ARGUMENT TYPE IN ALL CAPS.
"Boooop."  Captain Christopher Pike "Sitting. Poop thread."  BamaShooter 
The partially filled horizontal tank problem is a doozy but one I solved many years ago when I first started working and was fresh from college. I also derived a formula to solve the volume over partially submerged fillets in the bottom of a cylindrical tank using the Shell method from Calculus. It was very enjoyable and shit I have long forgotten how to do without some serious WD40.




worked this out with some help
volume (gal)=(length*(rad^2*ACOS((radinches liquid height)/rad)((radinches liquid height)*SQRT(2*rad*inches liquid heightinches liquid height^2))))/231 crude copy/paste/substitution from the excel spreadsheet i'm using. Thanks guys. 


Go out and stick the tank...
That's what we did before Veederroot. 

1911...
ALL I WANT IS BANG! BANG! BANG! 
Originally Posted By NwG: Go out and stick the tank... That's what we did before Veederroot. But then I couldn't appreciate the joys of middle management and numbers reporting and spreadsheets. 


Are we to assume this is a theoretical question (like homework)?
I fully understand what you're asking...... Unfortunately, I haven't done any calculus since about 1985, and I can't even remember how to set up the equation. But yes, it's an integral. If you have a couple of days, see if you can find a copy of "Calculus for the Practical Worker". It's straightforward enough to get you where you need to be. Now I'm going to have to pull out my old school books. Damn you!!!! never mind, I see you got what you're looking for 


AR15.COM is the worldâ€™s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 19962019 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.