i personally own a vermont castings catalytic wood stove.
i live in texas, so our 25 degree days are normally double digits, if that. we don't have 100 cold days a year. i paid 1 grand for the stove. i thought it would take 3 years to pay for itself. it did so in 2.
i have an inexhaustible supply of dry oak 1 hour away. can go get it whenever i want. it's great and an excuse to take the AR out to scalp coyotes with hollow points on my off days.
i like it. it's fun. fireplaces are ok but woodstoves are better. i don't live in a cold area, so for 2-3 months, it's fine.
our hard season is right now, in the end of the summer. it's 100 or more daily, with high humidity too. in michigan, the hard season is winter, in texas, it's the summer.
heats my house. 2k ft2 (square). when it's 25 outside, it's 75 inside.
i like vermont castings. i think it's good junk.