To whom it may concern:
While you are renovating your site, please consider the following corrections:
According to the Uniform Crime Report of 1999, 1535 persons between the age of 0 and 20 were killed by firearms in that year, not the 3500 your website claims.
There are several places where the claim is made that: "thousands of children are killed or injured in accidents involving an adult’s gun." According to the National Safety Council (www.nsc.org), in 1998 there were 700 unintentional injuries and deaths from firearms.
I also find it interesting that the website cites that "a gun in the home is 22 times more likely to kill or injure a friend or family member than an intruder." I believe this to be a misquote of an invalid statistic. The study by Kellerman, et al, in the _New England Journal of Medicine_ from 1993 that claimed that a firearm in the home was 42 times more likely to kill a friend or family member, but this statistic was derived from dubious data. 85% of the deaths in the data pool are suicides. There has never been a link established between suicide and gun ownership or the above quote would be sure to mention it. Any successful use of a firearm in self-defense is excluded from the sample, as the authors were not looking for benefits of gun ownership. This is a grave oversight since firearms are used to prevent a large number of violent crimes. Estimates range from 76,000 per year (1996 National Victim Crime Survey) to 2.1 million (_Point Blank: Guns & Violence in America_, Gary Kleck). Even the lower estimate would mean that for every murder committed with a firearm, a firearm averts 4 violent crimes. Also, one does not evaluate the deterrent effect of a police department by the number of bodies it produces, so it is absurd to think one can evaluate the benefit or cost of firearms ownership by counting incidents which result in a fatality.
Just let me say in closing that firearms safety is far too important an issue to jeopardize by using sensational statistics. In order to make a meaningful impact, you will need to gain the trust of the much-maligned gun owners of America. By urging mutual respect your organization has taken a step in the right direction. Another step would be to mend your facts so people using your materials sound more like concerned parents and not like gun-grabbing lunatics (like Kellerman).
Sincerely,
Joseph Ess
[email protected]