I would agree that its hard to get two of them that are the same.
An Edge Maduro is one of my absolute favorite stand bys, but its very disappointing when they aren't right. Typically quality from my b&m seems to be much better than from internet orders.
Decades and Decade edition limitada are two outstanding cigars, but even so I find the quality to be right there with the edges. I've had better luck with store bought ones, but even that won't guarantee a winner.
Royal Vintage cigars are kinda Meh flavorwise, but strong as hell with a full body. Had a shitty day? light one of these and you can forget about it for a while.
Fifteenth are pretty good, but not as good as a decade, and the RP connecticuts are well liked by everyone who has had one.
A winter collection is an excellent choice for a special event. My buddies and I all had them for a Christmas smoke last year. Everyone loved them.
The others I have tried I've not liked as much as these I've listed.