Creamy only for me! Belive it or not, this is my only weird irrational response scenario. I like peanuts and creamy peanut butter, but if someone sneaks me a PBJ with crunchy PB, I'll just about yak on the spot! I have no idea why, it's not the taste or anything, just something about it that makes me involuntarily want to hurl. That's it though, my one irrational involuntary response. I guess that makes me crazy ( or "nuts"??).