For about $530, you can get a new Beretta 390 12 gauge at Wal-Mart or Academy in my area (Baton Rouge, La). The only problem is that they have a 14.25" LOP and an impossible to cut down synthetic stock. Beretta makes 20 gauge 391 Urika youth models. However, they are well over the $500 mark unless you find one used. I would also recommend a Winchester Model 12. The Model 12 is a great (if not the best) pump gun. The Remington 870 is another option. The stock on either of these pump guns could be easily shortened and a recoil pad installed, if necessary. I've not handled one yet; but, Spartan by Remington offers an O/U for under $500. Academy has the Spartan 12 gauge O/U for $489. On the subject of Remington, if you get an 870, buy the Wingmaster instead of the Express. The wood and metal are much nicer on the Wingmaster models.