Quoted:
She needs something fairly decent graphics wise, as she does some photo work, but also needs something that isn't excessively hot or power hungry.
A ten key would be a plus... Basically an HP Elitebook 8540W would be a winner, as I have used one of those for a while at work... and its been great, despite my constant abuse. However, I can't seem to find those at a vendor that I know of, as they all seem to be corporate builds.
Any ideas? I would like to keep it under 2k, but still get a good machine that will last her 4 years or so.
Thanks.
The way I see it you basically have 2 options.
The HP elitebook 8570w or the Dell latitude E6530.
The lenovo's are ut of the running because the t530 runs way too hot and the w530 has that issue along with significant throttling issues which greatly reduces performance.
The elitebook 8570w is the most durable design (and coolest running), but it is more expensive as well.
Elitebook option #1: (1600 X 900 screen)
http://shopping1.hp.com/is-bin/INTERSHOP.enfinity/WFS/WW-USSMBPublicStore-Site/en_US/-/USD/ViewProductDetail-Start?ProductUUID=0BUQ7EN5hLsAAAE6aVxmfAGy&CatalogCategoryID=pJoQ7hacBbUAAAE21U9ObPSl
Elitebook option #2 (1080p screen)
http://shopping1.hp.com/is-bin/INTERSHOP.enfinity/WFS/WW-USSMBPublicStore-Site/en_US/-/USD/ViewProductDetail-Start?ProductUUID=UVIQ7EN5V98AAAE6s1xmfAGy&CatalogCategoryID=pJoQ7hacBbUAAAE21U9ObPSl
The dell (especially if bough through the outlet (new or certified refurbished)) can be significantly cheaper:
http://outlet.us.dell.com/ARBOnlineSales/Online/InventorySearch.aspx?c=us&cs=28&l=en&s=dfb&brandid=2801&fid=9390
I see several decent options in the outlet selection all round the $1k mark.
There is one with the 3720qm processor, 8GB of ram, nvidia 5200m graphics 320GB 7200 rpm hdd and 1080p screen for ~$1149. (near the top of 1st page, prices high to low)
There is another with a 3720qm processor, 8gb of ram, nvidia 5200m graphics, 320gb 7200 rpm hdd and 1600 X 900 screen for $1049-$1099 on the top of the second page (prices high to low)
Assuming those two options sell out you want to look for an e6530 with a quad core processor (3XXX series), nvidia 5200m graphics, 4GB ram minimum (8GB preferable), HDD of your choice (avoid any options with dell installed ssd's) and either a 1600 X 900 screen or 1080p screen (stay far away from 1366 X 768 options).
Back to my overall conclusion:
8570w advantages (with nvidia graphics, stay away from amd gpu equipped models):
Best durability (though the E6530 isn't anywhere near being "fragile" either)
Coolest running
Best port selection
Dell E6530 advantages:
cheaper (at least through the outlet)
more options (either through the business website configuration or retail website selection)
Better battery life (with larger than the standard ~55-65Wh battery, like the extended 85wh+ batteries) can get around 6.5+ hours doing basic tasks (due to optimus graphics switching) compared to ~4.5 with the elitebook.
Hopefully this makes your choice easier. (or at leas you are more informed)