http://pajamasmedia.com/blog/intent-to-deceive-bloombergs-gun-control-group-repeats-the-mexican-gun-canard/?singlepage=trueIntent to Deceive: Bloomberg’s Gun Control Group Repeats the ‘Mexican Gun Canard’
Again, an anti-gun group uses intentionally
misleading language to claim that most Mexican cartel weapons can be
traced to U.S. gun dealers.
Gun bans in Chicago and Washington, D.C., have been mercilessly
struck down by the courts. Concealed carry laws are being adopted and
expanded in states across the nation. Shooting sports are increasing in
popularity, and gun and ammunition sales remain near record highs.
It’s all enough to give the shrinking number of gun control advocates
in the United States apoplexy.
It’s also enough to force them into acts of desperation to prop up a failing ideology.
So it should come as little surprise that a
new report by Michael Bloomberg’s anti-gun organization — Mayors Against Illegal
Guns — relies completely upon deception to promote the billionaire
mayor’s anti-firearm jihad.
In recent years, the escalating drug cartel violence in
Mexico has claimed tens of thousands of lives, fueled in part by
thousands of guns illegally trafficked from the United States. In fact,
90% of guns recovered and traced from Mexican crime scenes originated
from gun dealers in the United States.
The first sentence of the report is factually correct. Thousands of
guns have been smuggled into Mexico by cartels, and theses smuggled
firearms have been one source of munitions for the drug gangs.
The second sentence, however, is masterfully deceptive … and
purposefully so. You’ll note that it says "90% of guns recovered and
traced from Mexican crime scenes originated from gun dealers in the
United States.”
Recovered and traced is the hinge for their entire argument.
It does not mean that 9 out of 10 guns recovered in Mexico come from
the United States, though Bloomberg and others clinging to this fallacy
would have you believe this.
What it means is that when Mexican authorities recover firearms from
a cartel, they try to discern their origins. The vast majority of
firearms recovered by Mexican authorities have no ties to the United
States in any way, shape, or form. Roughly 80% of guns recovered from
the cartels come from other nations, often former Soviet block nations
where AK-47s and other automatic weapons can be obtained on the black
market for next to nothing, in bulk.
The only firearms handed over to the ATF by the Mexican government
are those firearms they have reason to believe came from the United
States. These include weapons manufactured in the United States, as
well as weapons that bear a U.S. importer’s marks.
The Mexican government provides less than 20% of the weapons they
capture for tracing. Of nearly 100,000 weapons recovered from the
cartels, only 20 percent had been turned over to the U.S. for
identification. Of those, 18,000 were determined to have been
manufactured, sold, or imported from the United States. Less than half
of that fractional amount could be traced to U.S. gun dealers. The rest
were stolen or acquired through other means.
Of 100,000 weapons recovered from the cartels, just 7,900 — less than 8 percent — were traced to purchases from American gun dealers.
Data is still being analyzed, but preliminary reports indicate that in the majority of those sales, it was the
customers acting criminally — completing "strawman” purchases where people who pass the FBI’s
NCIS background check turn around and provide weapons to the cartels in exchange for pay.
Mayors Against Illegal Guns went out of its way to carefully craft
sentences that would create the illusion that American gun dealers were
the primary force behind the arming of the Mexican drug cartels.
In doing so, they smeared thousands of federal firearms licensees who
must comply with rigorous guidelines, and who could face the closure
of their businesses for demerits as minor as misfiled paperwork. This
is a dishonest attack by anti-gun politicians on law-abiding small
businessmen during the peak of a recession, orchestrated to push an
anti-American agenda.
And it isn’t even original.
President Barack Obama was
called out for this fraud over a year ago, when he tried to pass what became known as the "Mexican Gun Canard.” Mexican President Felipe Calderon
echoed the lie several months ago, and was also taken to task. That lesser
politicians thought they could spread the same dishonesty unchallenged
is absurd.
Unsurprisingly, these politicians have allies in the media more than
willing to further their propaganda efforts. Richard Esposito of ABC
News is just the latest purveyor of the lie, in his report "
Mexican Crime, American Guns.”
ABC News makes no effort at all to fact check the report of the
anti-gun group, which would easily have been refuted by congressional
testimony provided by ATF officials earlier this year. Instead, ABC
News provided an illusion of credibility to what is nothing more than
carefully crafted propaganda.
One can only assume that this shoddy journalism is just one result of David Westin’s
shameful destruction of ABC News. When standards aren’t upheld and agenda-driven "news” is allowed to thrive, credibility and ratings suffer.
Not that any of us should be surprised. Anti-gun organizations such
as the Brady Campaign, the Violence Policy Center, and Mayors Against
Illegal Guns rely upon deception and emotionalism for both funding and
to spread their message. Bloomberg himself
tried to profit from the massacre of U.S. troops by an enraged Muslim solider at Fort
Hood. That ABC news would be their beard is hardly surprising, either.
In particular, Brian Ross’ investigative team at The Blotter blog —
where Esposito published this propaganda — have a long track record of
inaccurate,
smear-based journalism.
Much of the American public is long past trusting politicians or the
mainstream media, precisely because of this sort of collaborative
deception. That these groups still bitterly cling to such transparent
propaganda efforts is perhaps a sign of how desperate they’ve become
attempting to defend an indefensible worldview.