OK, so those who have seen both, which one was better? Manhunter or Red Dragon?
Discuss....
Heres my take.
If I have to choose, hands down, Manhunter.
First of all, its directed by the Arfcom hall of famer, Michael Mann, of Heat fame
The music by Tangerine Dream is far better and interesting. I like the actors in it better for their parts. The color palette I like much more.
I like William Peterson as Graham way more than Ed Norton, Norton just seems to gay and wimpy. I like Dennis Farina as Crawford better than Keitel, although I think the best Crawford was Scott Glenn in Silence. The Reba character is a toss up...Joan Allen or Emily Watson...ehh, either or. Tom Noonan is far more creepy and scary as Doloarhyde than Ralph Fiennes. Noonan is hands down better. And I like Stephan Lang better as Lounds of Phillip Seymour Hoffman....
I also like aspects of Manhunter much more. The final breaking of Dolarhyde when he sees Reba getting dropped off by the other film guy was much cooler in Manhunter..."No, not Francis, Francis is gone, Francis is gone forever...."
Interestingly enough how different visually the two are, considering the cinematographer was the same, Dante Spinotti....I like the brilliant color palette of Manhunter much better than the muted dull palette of Red Dragon. The color in Manhunter was amazing....
The music in my book was far more interesting and ethereal in Manhunter than the standard symphonic stuff in Dragon. Tangerine Dream rules....
Also found it interesting that Delaurentis Group was responsible for both....
So in my book Manhunter all the way...
What say you guys?