User Panel
Posted: 10/16/2004 1:39:33 PM EDT
Poll coming...
Based on musical talent, influence on culture, and worldwide appeal. |
|
Ever? Beatles, hands down.
Stones? Arguable in counting fame, but their influence and appeal was nowhere near as broad. Led Zep? Possibly, but they didn't really change Rock, just rode the wave and rode it well. Queen and Van Halen don't belong on the list. |
|
Van Halen (with Roth, not Hagar) !!!!!!!! Without them, there'd be no Metalica and other similars. EDIT: Just noticed that you added the poll and actually put in Van Halen. I am stunned to say the least!! |
|
|
I'm confident that I've listed the top five. Curious to see what order they get ranked in. |
|
|
I'm pretty sure that Queen would win a true worldwide poll. I think they would win that criteria and musical talent, although VH would be up there in musical talent, too (but the other three had more influence). |
|
|
Greatest 'Rock Band'? Led Zepellin…… …Stairway to Heaven…
FUN "STAIRWAY" FACTS: * As of January 7, 1991, "Led Zeppelin IV" had been certified platinum times ten (ten million copies sold). * Stairway to Heaven" remains the biggest-selling sheet music in the history of rock. An average hit sells 10,000 to 15,000 copies. "Stairway to Heaven" has sold more than one million copies. * "Stairway" is still played 4,203 times a year by the country's sixty-seven largest AOR (album-oriented rock) radio stations, according to trade magazine MONDAY MORNING REPLAY. How many times has it been played since it was released? ASCAP, the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, refuses to release exact figures, but here's a rough guess: Figure that on each AOR station in America, the song was played five times a day during its first three months of existence; twice a day for the next nine months; once a day for the next four years; and two to three times a week for the next fifteen years. There are roughly six hundred AOR and "classic" rock stations in the U.S., which means that "Stairway" has been broadcast a minimum of 2,874 times. At eight minutes per spin, roughly 23 million minutes -- almost forty-four solid years -- have been devoted to the song. So far. * In 1982, a California State Assembly consumer-protection-committee hearing featured testimony from "experts" who claimed that "Stairway," when played backward, contained the words: "I sing because I live with Satan. The Lord turns me off -- there's no escaping it. Here's to my sweet Satan, whose power is Satan. He will give you 666. I live for Satan." Using a reel-to-reel tape machine, *we* played the song backward. The greatest shock was that the words sounded just like "Stairway to Heaven," only in Urdu. In the verse that begins "If there's a bustle in your hedgerow," there is indeed something uttered that sounds like "sayntin." Evidence of a demonic message? Or was the backward-masking controversy started by a failing electronics firm as a ploy to get teenagers to ruin turntables by spinning them backward? * On January 23, 1991, John Sebastian, owner and general manager of KLSK FM in Albuquerque, New Mexico, played the song for twenty-four solid hours to inaugurate a format change to classic rock. It played more than two hundred times, eliciting hundreds of angry calls and letters. Police showed up with guns drawn, once after a listener reported that the deejay had apparently suffered a heart attack, later because of suspicion that -- this being eight days into the Gulf War -- the radio station had been taken hostage by terrorists dispatched by Zeppelin freak Saddam Hussein. Weirdest of all, lots of listeners didn't move the dial. "Turns out a lot of people listened to see when we would finally stop playing it." Beatlles!!??!?!??!?…… NO WAY are the Beatles a Rock Band! Elevator Muzak at best Andy |
|
But since all of these were "before my time" I would have to include a more modern Metalica
|
|
How about Pink Floyd??????
Edited to add... They all are great. I had to vote for Van Halen out of the ones you listed due to pure hard rockin , kick ass music. I agree with one of the previous entries.... with Dave Lee Roth. Saw them twice in concert back in the early eighties. KICK ASS!!!! Eddie's guitar and Alex's drummin and Roth as a front man. Just great!!! Also how about DEEP PURPLE!!! |
|
|
Your poll is flawed. I didn't see a selection for Pink Floyd.
|
|
Led Zeppelin, seen them in concert three times back in the day
GM |
|
Well, since N*Sync isn't on there I voted for the Beatles, but
|
|
Queen and Van Halen dont belong here. You left out some heavies in particular if your talking influence, The Byrds, The Band, Crosby,Stills, Nash & Young, Eric Clapton with Ginger Baker and Creme, Morrison and the Doors... The Byrds would be my choice as the individual members all formed influential bands of their own as did Creme, Clapton and Winwood being an example. Out of your choice I believe Zeppelin takes it. My 2 cents
|
|
+1million, trillion, gillian. Hello, Dark Side of the Moon, one of the largest selling albums of all time, I've got your world wide popularity right here. Van Halen? No staying power. Aerosmith deserves to be on the list before VH, or Queen. |
|
|
+1 |
|
|
CREAM!!!! Clapton!!!! I'm listening to Cream as I type this hehehe.
|
|
another right in for "the who".
Down at the Astoria the scene was changing, Bingo and rock were pushing out X-rating, We were the first band to vomit in the bar, And find the distance to the stage too far, Meanwhile it's getting late at ten o'clock, Rock is dead they say, Long live rock. Long live rock, I need it every night, Long live rock, come on and join the line, Long live rock, be it dead or alive. People walk in sideways pretending that they're leaving, We put on our makeup and work out all the lead-ins, Jack is in the alley selling tickets made in Hong Kong, Promoter's in the pay box wondering where the band's gone, Back in the pub the governor stops the clock, Rock is dead, they say, Long live rock. Long live rock, I need it every night, Long live rock, come on and join the line, Long live rock, be it dead or alive. Landslide, rocks are falling, Falling down 'round our very heads, We tried but you were yawning, Look again, rock is dead, rock is dead, rock is dead. The place is really jumping to the high-watt amps, 'Til a 20-inch cymbal fell and cut the lamps, In the blackout they dance right into the aisle, And as the doors fly open even the promoter smiles, Someone takes his pants off and the rafters knock, Rock is dead, they say, Long live rock, long live rock, long live rock. Long live rock, long live rock, long live rock, Long live rock, long live rock, long live rock. Long live rock, I need it every night, Long live rock, come on and join the line, Long live rock, be it dead or alive. |
|
Seriously, that's a pretty narrow view of music. If you can even get the contest down to 5 bands, every one of them having been played to death on the radio.........well......sad, just sad.
|
|
|
Amen! As far as pure talent no one else can compare. Each of the 3 are the best at what they do. These guys are way underated in the USA. They are truly huge worldwide. 30 years and still going strong. hail2.gif Have to admit though that the Beatles made the most impact & change, even though John Lennon was a leftist commie. |
|
|
I don't get this comment--the question is not "which is the only band worth listening to." I think most true fans of music like variety and have eclectic tastes. |
|
|
I would have to go with Aerosmith. I can't believe you have Queen on the poll but not Aerosmith.
|
|
|
Which Version is it this week? Hell, Great White is probably still touring. By staying power, I didn't mean that they were no longer around, or touring. Pink Floyd, The Beatles, and Zepplin have been broken up for how long? The Beatles, Pink Floyd, Zepplin, and the Who will never perform with all of the original members. The music genious. Their music has no staying power. They are no longer relevent. Yes, Eddie can play guitar, but there are a lot of guitarists. The question is not who was the greatest guitarist, or most relevent guitarist, it's Greatest Rock Band of all time. VH didn't have near as many great Albums as the others listed, nor songs, nor performances. They don't rate. |
|
|
Zeppelin!!!! Jimmy Page is a damn genius and he had complete control over everything they put on their albums. Peter Grant made sure the band got complete artistic control when they signed their deal with IIRC Atlantic Records, he wasn't afraid to break every bone in the record execs body neither.
|
|
I voted for the Beatles for overall popularity and the invasion they started in the 60's.
Van Halen didn't spawn the heavy metal bands of the 80's, Led Zeppelin was at the forefront of heavy metal 10 + years earlier. Stones could take it for longevity alone and to be honest I like them the best out of the bands listed. Van Halen and Queen do not belong there as someone stated earlier....... Vito...The Beatles were a Rock and Roll band....Thye music evolved and that brought us the Who, Zep etc. At that point it was called "rock" (with the Roll dropped) |
|
speaking of Pink Floyd.... www.ar15.com/forums/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=283843
|
|
Agree, VH isn't a metal band, what they did was spawn the hair bands of the 80's. Shudder. |
|
|
+1 ...as well as Queen. OT: I can't get enough of those album covers... |
|
|
Stryfe....I can't stand van Halen music and I can say I never bought any of their albums.....uggh...They are in the Meatloaf category with me.
|
|
Got to go with THE BEATLES Second The Rolling Stones Third Led Zep |
|
|
Stryfe....I can't stand van Halen music and I can say I never bought any of their albums.....uggh...They are in the Meatloaf category with me.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.