Gentlemen,
As an NRA member and long time gun nut...I absolutely believe in the literal translation of the Second Amendment to the Constitution and the RIGHT it confers upon all Americans to legally own firearms.
Further, I believe that any law that infringes, restricts, curtails, or impedes our right to use, shoot, carry (open or concealed), manipulate, fondle, worship or do any other damn thing we choose to or with our firearms is an illegal law and should be declared unconstitutional on its face.
Having marked my territory, I will now state what may be the obvious to some but which I have so far failed to see framed in our discussion so far:
We gun owners are not dealing with rationale, logical beings when we argue with Antis. They are liberals. They don't use logic to frame an argument, they use FEELINGS. They argue with their feelings, not their brain. They don't make an argument for individual rights either. They wish for the "commune good".
Since Antis are irrational and emotional, nothing you can say will change their already-made-up minds. You can show an Anti a copy of More Guns, Less Crime by Dr. Lott, take the time to [try to] explain to the Anti the statistical methodology and models, and the results, and pretty soon, you just watch their eyes glaze over. For the most part, they can't grasp the facts (Sort of like the OJ jury trying to understand DNA testing?), and even if they could, they don't really want to live with the results, so they simply declare the study to be irreparably flawed and yielding false results. "Lott is wrong", the more genteel libs will intone. "Lott is a biased gun nut trying to push an evil gun agenda", the more polarized will blather. Either way...it doesn't matter...they ain't listening.
Since firearms are designed to kill humans and little innocent creatures (No argument there...), and since they don't own any firearms, Antis don't understand why we "need" a firearm for any reason.
Since they strongly believe in wealth redistribution, they don't understand why we just don't stop buying firearms, supplies and ammo and just don't give all the money spent supporting the evil arms industry back to noble causes that our benevolent government may choose to support or to charity.
Antis see the Constitution as a "Living" document, subject to the every changing "needs" of a modern, evolving society. With respect to the Second Amendment anyway, Antis see the words of the Founding Fathers as just a bunch of hot air.
When even a proven LIAR like Dr. Bellisle publishes a pack of lies against guns, the Antis line up to praise and buy. A FRAUD? No way...they say. When presented with the incontrovertible FACTS (Pesky things facts.) that Bellisle lied and made shit up...the Antis simply say..."Well, so what...it was for a good cause anyway.) For the Antis, the cause holds primacy over all. They just say, "So what...I still don't like guns...and I still don't see why you "need" them!" [shock] (For info: Those are the EXACT words my sister in law from San Luis Obispo County, CA spoke to me a few months ago in our ongoing battle over the Second Amendment.)
While I admire and applaud your sand in taking these people on...I fear you are just pissing in the surf. I don't think it will have much of an impact.
Good luck anyway.
[beer]