Is the Death Penalty wrong? I've heard this so many times it's making me sick. Being an old soldier (and my local letters editor thinks I'm a crank) take this with whatever grain of salt you feel it deserves.
I think that Capital punishment is not only effective, but is actually necessary - and becoming moreso. Research recidivism - you should be able to find information on that from "three strikes" supporters. FIlter according to violent crimes.
Now, let us take a hypothetical (I know, what if there were no hypothetical questions?) Place a man on trial for the murder of, say, two people. Prove his guilt beyond any reasonable doubt - the standard of justice. Now, we have two choices...
1) Incarceration. It has been said that one should "Kill a man if necessary, but to incarcerate him destroys his dignity and yours." In any case, you then place him on the public dole for security, housing, and sustenance, and he is probaly living better than he has before (and is definintely living better than me!)
2) Execute him. In doing so, you remove a dangerous element from society, disabling any firther crimes being committed by that one man. It may only be one man, but it is a start.
Another interesting philosophical point - in ancient Rome, Roman citizens were NOT to be shackled or manacled when arrested. See the point above (which can, I believe, be attributed to Robert Anson Heinlein.)
Murder, kidnapping, rape, arson (where personal injury or death is involved,) attempted murder, assault with intent, and probably other crimes, should be treated and handled as capital offences. It has often been argued that the death penalty is morally wrong, but so is releasing a known danger back into the general population. So is placing a known danger in an environment where he can escape control or custody.
To kill a man is a sin. To release a known killer into the population (for whatever reason) is a greater sin, and the man who releases him should be held responsible for any more lives lost.
I am at your disposal for discussion inthe backchannel
FFZ
[email protected]