There actually is pin holes where the eagle was. It is also visibly cleaner in the shape of the eagle underneath where the pin once was. My picture may be a bit deceptive as it makes the hat look unusually bright and clean, since I used a flash maybe. Also, the hat has visible sweat stains inside, which may also explain the rumply leather inside. As to poor stitching, I really would not know good from bad. I've tried to find someone locally that knows this stuff to no avail. My sisters picked it up at a local (Denver, CO) Antique shop. The lady who owned that specific booth was apparently crying and said that her husband, the actual proprietor of that booth was killed in a shoot out a few nights earlier. She was trying to liquidate his products to pay for the funeral. The man who owned the shop vouched for the late dealers credibilty and stated he was a well respected dealer in WW2 relics. How far that goes I really can't say since I wasn't there. I've seen some knock offs of armbands and patches and such and all were pretty obvious. If this is a fake, as a novice, I would judge it to be a well contructed one, and going the extra mile to add the stamp of a legitimate German tailor seems far fetched to me, but i don't know much obviously. I'm having trouble rectifying the above two opinions with that of Panzer earlier on who said it looked authentic. It would be nice if someone with some definite knowledge would weigh in and maybe provide a link or some idea of how he reached his conclusion. Somehow I doubt that will happen, but i do appreciate the help I've received thus far. Thanks guys.