User Panel
Posted: 8/18/2013 5:43:53 PM EDT
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't
http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/Articles/2013/08/15/12-Weapons-That-Changed-Everything.aspx#page1 By JOSH HERR, The Fiscal Times August 15, 2013 As the battle over gun rights in America reaches more and more baroque levels it’s easy to lose track of how we got here. Weaponry and war has been a concern for humanity from its very earliest days. Empires from Greece, Rome and Persia to Napoleonic France and Colonial England have all been built on a backbone of superior firepower. From Roman’s peasants fearing Hannibal’s elephants to Irish farmers dreading the site of Viking warships on the horizon, from Paul Revere’s "The British are coming!” to the 1950’s "Duck and Cover” drills, weaponry has haunted our nightmares for as long as it’s fueled the dreams of boys and conquerors. The right of protection against tyranny was so important to our founding fathers that they included it as the Second Amendment to the Constitution. This debate still rages, as we weigh the costs of our gun culture against this principle. Technology, as always, drives innovation. And that is just as true with weapons as it is with the Internet. Just as there is a through line that stretches from the Sears catalog to Amazon.com, there is an equally clear line from the sword to the predator drone. <snip> |
|
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't View Quote lol |
|
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't View Quote Because its a list of outdated weapons |
|
Quoted:
...the M16/AR15 isn't View Quote God isn't real, drugs should be legal. |
|
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't View Quote Considering the article author's ignorance, I'm not surprised. Technically called the “Automat Kalashnikova – 47,” the AK was everything its American counterpart the M-16 was not -- cheap, easy to manufacture, reliable and accurate, and it didn’t hurt that it just looked cooler. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Considering the article author's ignorance, I'm not surprised. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Considering the article author's ignorance, I'm not surprised. Technically called the “Automat Kalashnikova – 47,” the AK was everything its American counterpart the M-16 was not -- cheap, easy to manufacture, reliable and accurate, and it didn’t hurt that it just looked cooler. |
|
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't View Quote In before Rusted_Ace gets here and the sure to be civil conversation regarding the article. |
|
I always consult "The Fiscal Times" when forming my opinions about history making weaponry.
Especially an idiot who describes the M-16 family as not "accurate" as compared to the AK. |
|
Bone
Phalanx Gladius Longbow Gunpowder weapons (900ad) Rifled barrel Colt revolver Belt Fed MG Tanks Atomic Bomb Ak47 Drones |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Considering the article author's ignorance, I'm not surprised. Technically called the “Automat Kalashnikova – 47,” the AK was everything its American counterpart the M-16 was not -- cheap, easy to manufacture, reliable and accurate, and it didn’t hurt that it just looked cooler. I guess it depends on your definition of "accurate" is. |
|
The minie gun wasn't proven in the American Civil War. It was proven during the Crimean War and later the Sepoy Mutiny. The American Civil War proved the viability of the breechloader and repeater.
I think the aeroplane is the other weapon system that was overlooked. I'd take out #1 Club in favor of the influence of airpower. Airpower made behind the lines airdrops possible. It made the battleship obsolete (sorry, while the submarine was a big threat to the big ships, even the submarines were vulnerable to the aeroplane). |
|
"Changed" is past tense. M16s are "changing" the world as we speak
|
|
Quoted:
Because its a list of outdated weapons View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Because its a list of outdated weapons This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. |
|
Quoted:
This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK THE STG-43 did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Because its a list of outdated weapons This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK THE STG-43 did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. How about if we give credit where it is actually due? |
|
Some good choices in that list, but some strange ones as well. A phalanx is a weapon?
The problem is that once you get further along in history, the line blurs between a new weapon, and the engraftment of a new technology onto an existing weapon. In other words, what is one listing: a weapon or a component? For example, ought one to choose a lever-action rifle or bolt action rifle as an example of a breech-loading repeating rifle, or would it make more sense to recognize the two technological advancements that did the most to make breech-loading possible (brass casings and primers)? Does it make more sense to say the rifle, or the minie ball? My list: 1. Bone/rock - use something other than yourself to inflict damage 2. Metal blades - the mainstay of human weaponry for what? 7000 years or more? 3. Stirrups - cavalry has arrived 4. Gunpowder/siege cannon - self-evident 5. The ring/socket bayonet - the firearm and the pike rolled into one 6. The revolver - first practical repeating arm 7. The metallic cartridge - the foundation for the holy grail of weapons makers (the breechloader); also the foundation for all the recoil/gas operated repeating arms ever made 8. The tank - the cavalry goes industrial 9. The airplane - I think this ought to also include the aircraft carrier 10. The submarine - pretty self-evident as well 11. Rockets/missiles - also self-evident 12. Nuclear weapons - also self-evident 13. The computer Yeah, I had to go one over. And all of that almost completely ignores naval warfare for the vast majority of human history, but I don't really feel adequate to that task. At a minimum I think one must consider including the rudder, possibly oars, the ram, the sail, honorable mention to the corvus, Greek fire, and all of the enhancements to ships that I don't really understand but that allowed them to tack ever further into the wind. |
|
Quoted: The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't <> <snip> View Quote The AK is a peasants gun designed to be built in caves by smashing rocks together. The AR is a sophisticated technologically artistic piece of machinery. |
|
Quoted:
The AK set a new standard that the world had to play by. View Quote I have to agree with the above. Cheap, easy to make, reliable, accurate enough, etc. The AR-15 is a good platform but I don't think it had the change that the ak did. The ar's big move in my mind was the move to save weight in both design and ammo size. A very good platform, but the ak will have a greater legacy. |
|
|
Quoted: How about if we give credit where it is actually due? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Because its a list of outdated weapons This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK THE STG-43 did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. How about if we give credit where it is actually due? |
|
I would not pick the AK just any rifle. Winter War was won by bolt action rifles. But liberal news what do you expect...commie rifle is their pick
|
|
Quoted: How about if we give credit where it is actually due? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Because its a list of outdated weapons This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK THE STG-43 did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. How about if we give credit where it is actually due? Yes and no. Despite what Kalashnikov says, the AK-47 was obviously based off the idea of the STG.44, however I still think the AK had more of a historical impact on the world of small arms. The STG only saw limited service over just a few years before it evolved into the CETME and G3 and the concept of the Assault Rifle (small, intermediate cartridge rifle/carbine) was pretty much abandoned. While the rest of the world was using full size Battle Rifles like the M14, FAL, G3, etc. Russia was about the only country using an Assault Rifle, which the rest of the world eventually started using throughout the Cold War. |
|
Quoted: I guess it depends on your definition of "accurate" is. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Considering the article author's ignorance, I'm not surprised. Technically called the "Automat Kalashnikova – 47,” the AK was everything its American counterpart the M-16 was not -- cheap, easy to manufacture, reliable and accurate, and it didn’t hurt that it just looked cooler. I guess it depends on your definition of "accurate" is. Here's another Hollywood also did their part, preferring its curved clip |
|
Quoted: I would not pick the AK just any rifle. Winter War was won by bolt action rifles. But liberal news what do you expect...commie rifle is their pick View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Yes and no. Despite what Kalashnikov says, the AK-47 was obviously based off the idea of the STG.44, however I still think the AK had more of a historical impact on the world of small arms. The STG only saw limited service over just a few years before it evolved into the CETME and G3 and the concept of the Assault Rifle (small, intermediate cartridge rifle/carbine) was pretty much abandoned. While the rest of the world was using full size Battle Rifles like the M14, FAL, G3, etc. Russia was about the only country using an Assault Rifle, which the rest of the world eventually started using throughout the Cold War. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The AK-47 is on the list, the M16/AR15 isn't Because its a list of outdated weapons This is true, and as bad as the article is... the AK THE STG-43 did change everything - the AR type rifle was a response to it, a refinement of the idea of a high-capacity intermediate power carbine. How about if we give credit where it is actually due? Yes and no. Despite what Kalashnikov says, the AK-47 was obviously based off the idea of the STG.44, however I still think the AK had more of a historical impact on the world of small arms. The STG only saw limited service over just a few years before it evolved into the CETME and G3 and the concept of the Assault Rifle (small, intermediate cartridge rifle/carbine) was pretty much abandoned. While the rest of the world was using full size Battle Rifles like the M14, FAL, G3, etc. Russia was about the only country using an Assault Rifle, which the rest of the world eventually started using throughout the Cold War. So if Russia's rifle was popular the world over, and it's based on an earlier German rifle, shouldn't the basis rifle be the more influential item? Kinda like Maxim's design being copied and modified by Vickers; Maxim would get the credit for influencing the Brits. |
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.