My girlfriend loves shooting my 870 Police Magnum (4901) with target loads, but the length of pull is far too long: her left arm needs to be fully extended to reach the slide forearm. She doesn't mind 12 gauge, and she even shot a Brenneke slug and didn't mind the recoil. But that fairly mild target load causes her to step back at each shot. I think, though, the fit of the gun is partly at fault. I've begun to think about a shotgun just for her. This is for defense and gun range fun for now. Later we may get longer barrels and try thrown clay targets. Farther yet in the future, we may go bird hunting together.
Because of the possible defensive use of these shotguns, I think that having an 870, with the same controls as my Police Magnum, is a good idea, rather than some other brand. But we're open to alternatives. I see that Remington has a Wingmaster Jr. with a 12" length of pull, shorter than even the 13" LOP on the youth 870 Express (it's 14" or 14 -1/4" on the non-youth models). But these are 20 gauge guns. My thinking is that if we can both use 12 gauge that's a better choice, costwise and tactically.
She would love a high gloss wood stock and forearm. Ideally, I'd find a short barrelled 12 gauge Wingmaster with a shorter LOP stock or an 870 Police with a short, plain wooden buttstock. I'm suprised Remington doesn't offer them. Winchester has the 1300 Sporting Field Compact, the 1300 Ranger Gloss Compact, both with 24" barrels, and the 1300 Ranger Compact, with a 22" barrel - all with 13" LOP. Browning offers the BPS micro, with a 22" barrel and a 13-1/4" LOP, but it's a 20 gauge, like the Wingmaster Jr. On the semiauto side, Browning offers the 12 gauge Gold Ladies Sporting Clays with 13-1/2" LOP and a long 28" barrel. Mossberg has the 13" LOP, 24" barrel, 500 Bantam, available in 12 gauge. So where is Remington in all of this? If nothing else, why don't they simply offer replacement wooden forearms and also buttstocks with a 13" LOP? I'd put those on a second 870P and be done with it.
GL